Tax reform is still possible, but don’t expect it to be easy, quick or painless, said speakers at a tax forum in Cape Elizabeth Thursday night.
Arranged and moderated by Rep. Cynthia Dill, D-Cape Elizabeth, the forum brought together a panel of legislators from both parties and representatives from the state’s municipal association, planning office and chamber of commerce.
They discussed reasons a tax reform bill that would have reduced the income tax to 6.5 percent failed last year in the Senate, and what would have to be different in a future bill for it to succeed.
To compensate for lower income and capital gains tax, the failed bill would have broadened the sales tax and increased meals and lodging taxes, among other things. Rep. John Piotti, D-Unity, chairman of the House Taxation Committee, said it would have shifted more of the burden to out-of-staters, encouraged business and the economy and been more equitable than the current tax system.
But panelists said it was viewed as just another attempt to take money from the pockets of Maine residents, and that legislators didn’t feel assured that it wouldn’t end up resulting in a net tax increase.
“Our biggest concern from day one is … lowering the tax burden,” said Dana Connors, president of the Maine Chamber of Commerce. “The only way to really significantly reduce the tax burden is to lower spending.”
The chamber opposed the bill.
Sen. Karl Turner, R-Cumberland, supported the bill, but felt that many of his fellow senators were also suspicious that it would result in more state spending.
“We want to make sure that we’re really talking reform, not just tax-shifting,” said Anne Swift-Kayatta, president of the Maine Municipal Association and a Cape Elizabeth councilor. In an interview after the forum, Swift-Kayatta echoed the chamber’s position that the most important step to lower taxes is to decrease state spending.
Had the tax reform package passed, Piotti said, it would have made Maine less reliant on the sales tax from big-ticket items like building supplies and appliances, which people tend to hold off buying when the economy takes a dip, and might have helped avoid the $195 million deficit Maine is currently facing.
But Martha Connors, director of the Maine State Planning Office, said that wouldn’t necessarily be a good thing. If tax revenues stayed the same or increased despite the decline in the economy, it would mean that Maine residents were paying more at a time when they can little afford to do so.
Gov. John Baldacci opposed the package because he believes the state needs to reduce spending, she said, and he “felt that the time hadn’t come for it yet.”
“… I’m looking forward to achieving it (tax reform) in my lifetime,” she said.
Dill said that some form of tax reform could be included in the appropriations bill the Legislature is currently considering.
About 15 people attended the forum, which was held in the Town Council chambers.
Comments are no longer available on this story