10 min read

During the past five years, Maine has sacrificed 41 soldiers to the war in Iraq – part of the more than 4,000 Americans who have given their lives to the conflict.

This week, Iraq War veterans and surviving family members in southern Maine join with the rest of the country to commemorate the fifth anniversary of the war’s start. Their deeply felt experiences remain fresh, and the scars – physical and emotional – have yet to completely heal.

The ongoing debate about whether the U.S. should withdraw from Iraq is a painful one. Those who fought don’t want to see the U.S. pull out before the mission is completed, and those who have lost loved ones worry that a withdrawal while the situation remains unstable could mean that their sons and husbands died for nothing.

“I supported the mission while I was there and I support it now. I don’t think we should pull out,” said Sgt. Curtis Mills of Shapleigh, who was nearly killed by a roadside bomb blast in September of 2003.

Valerie Swiger, of South Portland, whose son was killed while he was on duty in Baqubah, Iraq last March, doesn’t want a withdrawal because that could mean the soldiers who now won’t be coming home “have died for naught.”

“Too many have given their lives” for the U.S. to pull out now, Swiger said.

Advertisement

“I know people disagree with this war. But I just don’t want them to forget about the guys still over there, ” said Gunnery Sgt. Scott Nichols of Waterboro, who served with the Marine Corps Reserves. “I don’t go out of my way to talk about (the Iraq War), but I don’t think that we can just pull out.”

Harold “Butch” Freeman of Gorham was a staff sergeant who served with Company B of the 133rd Combat Engineering Battalion. He was severely injured in an explosion in Iraq in December 2004, and fears the consequences if U.S. troops are withdrawn.

In fact, he believes a lot of innocent people would die if the U.S. left Iraq now.

A closer look

1st Sgt. Phil Ceaser

Ceaser, 59, of Scarborough, spent a year in Iraq serving with what was then known as B Company of the 133rd Engineering Battalion based in Mosul. The unit’s name has now been changed to the 262 Engineer Company.

Advertisement

He said the engineers mostly spent their time building roads, schools, soccer fields and medical clinics. Ceaser’s unit also rebuilt an airfield in a town south of Mosul and built protective walls around U.S. military bases and Iraqi government buildings to shield them from car bombs.

Ceaser said when the 262nd first arrived in Iraq, in late 2004, the base in Mosul came under attack from mortars and rockets as many as four times a week. He also went through a couple roadside bomb attacks and said, “That’s not pleasant, I can tell you that.”

He was home on leave on Dec. 21, 2004, when a concierge tent, at Camp Marez in Mosul, was ripped apart by a bomb. The attack killed 21 soldiers and wounded 76 more.

Despite that attack and the nearly 4,000 deaths of U.S. troops, Ceaser said, “I think we’re doing the right thing over there. I fully support the mission and I would go back again if my wife would let me.”

Valerie Swiger

Swiger lost her son, Sgt. Jason Swiger, on March 25, 2007. He was 24 at the time and serving with the 82nd Airborne. He was on his third tour of duty and was killed by a roadside bomb in Baqubah, Iraq, while handing out candy to Iraqi children.

Advertisement

Valerie Swiger said her son wanted to be in the military ever since he was a child, when he would visit his uncle’s house in Pennsylvania and watch paratroopers at a nearby military base jumping out of airplanes during training.

She remembers watching television coverage of the roadside explosion that ultimately killed four U.S. soldiers, although at the time she didn’t know her son was one of them.

Since her son was killed, Swiger continues to send care packages to those from Maine who are serving in Iraq. She also sends messages of condolence to other families who have lost loved ones in the war.

In addition, Swiger, who got into a public battle with the South Portland City Council over placing yellow ribbons on telephone poles around town, now puts the ribbons on private property and at local businesses to continue to remind people the war is still going on.

Although Swiger believes the U.S. made the right decision to invade Iraq, she doesn’t like the war and advocates for a pullback. She said U.S. forces should patrol Iraq’s borders to prevent insurgents from crossing into Iraq from neighboring countries.

“I believe Iraq would then take care of itself,” Swiger said.

Advertisement

Staff Sgt. Butch Freeman

Staff Sgt. Harold “Butch” Freeman, 46, was training troops at Fort Drum, N.Y., when the war started. He feels the decision to go to Iraq was the right one.

Although no weapons of mass destruction were ever found – one of President Bush’s initial justifications for the war – Freeman has another justification: “Hundreds of thousands were killed in Saddam (Hussein’s) reign of terror.”

Freeman believes that if the U.S. pulls out now, “a lot of people are going to die.” He argued that everyone knew going into the war that it would be a long one.

“If the politicians thought this was going to be a cake walk, they should get out of office,” he said.

He is proud of the work his unit did while it was deployed in Iraq. The 262nd completed 1,500 missions, Freeman said, including building five schools. He became a new grandfather six months ago, and said seeing the smiles on the faces of the Iraqi children made his service “worth it all.”

Advertisement

Freeman is now permanently disabled after being seriously injured when a bomb exploded and ripped apart a concierge tent at Camp Marez on Dec. 21, 2004.

The blast blew a hole the size of a softball in Freeman’s right leg, near the groin area, and fractured his thighbone.

Ryann Roukey

Ryann Roukey’s husband, Sgt. Larry Roukey, was killed in an explosion on April 26, 2004, six weeks after his arrival in Iraq. He was a member of the Army Reserves, who joined up after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.

Although it’s been nearly four years since her husband died, Roukey feels like it all happened “just yesterday.”

She was left as a single parent, now raising her children, Nicholas and Sonya, by herself. Roukey said it’s been tough financially, emotionally and physically, but she feels blessed to have her children by her side.

Advertisement

Roukey remembers being “surprised and shocked” when her husband was initially deployed. “I didn’t think the war was as serious as it really was,” she said.

Roukey said she has mixed feelings about the war. She knows a lot of people who think U.S. troops should come home now, but she knows a lot of other people who believe the soldiers are still needed in Iraq.

“I think it’s just so unforeseen what would happen if (the troops) come home,” she said.

Staff Sgt. Jason Dube

Staff Sgt. Jason Dube, 30, of Old Orchard Beach, was in Iraq with the 262 Engineer Company from March 2004 to March 2005.

He said his interactions with Iraqi civilians were mostly positive, even though it was sometimes hard to tell who was a friend and who was not. In fact, his unit came under attack “every now and then,” Dube said, but he wasn’t at Camp Marez when the concierge tent was bombed.

Advertisement

“I was not on base that day. I was off working on a runway repair project. I’m glad I didn’t see it,” he said.

Dube knew it would be a possibility that his unit would be deployed after war was declared. He remembers being told to be ready because the 262nd was on a list of units to be sent overseas.

At the time he left for Iraq, Dube was engaged. After coming back, he has married and he and wife, Becky, now have a 13-month old child.

Although he doesn’t like to get into a political discussion of whether troops should stay or go, he’s proud of the work he and his unit accomplished while in Iraq, Dube said.

Nancy Kelley

“I won’t believe that my son died in vain,” said Nancy Kelley of Old Orchard Beach, whose son, Capt. Christopher Scott Cash, was killed while on duty in Baqubah, Iraq on June 24, 2004.

Advertisement

In fact, Kelley and her husband, Bob, have never wavered in their support for the war and believe that President Bush had no choice but to invade Iraq.

“We’d tried diplomacy for 10 years. How much longer were we supposed to keep trying, especially in the dangerous world we now live in?” Bob Kelley asked.

“All I know is that I am a very proud mother and I stood and still do stand behind my government. I know Chris was a proud American first and foremost. He died protecting his fellow soldiers and serving his country,” Nancy Kelley said.

Cash was 36 when he died, and his parents had not seen him for the previous two years before he was deployed. Cash was stationed in North Carolina at the time, although he grew up in Old Orchard Beach and attended Old Orchard Beach High School, where he was a track star.

Kelley said she’s turned the grief over her son’s death into positive action.

She not only runs the Hugs of Love-Remember Our Troops support group, but also holds an annual road race and walk to benefit the Capt. Christopher Scott Cash scholarships offered at both Old Orchard Beach High School and Thornton Academy in Saco.

Advertisement

Kelley said she and her husband have trouble sleeping since her son was killed almost four years ago. “I’m just as sad as the day Chris died,” she said.

“I never thought I’d have a picture of the battle where my son died hanging in my living room. But I have no regrets for my son. He did a lot in his 36 years and he was doing exactly what he wanted to be doing,” Kelley added.

Gunnery Sgt. Scott Nichols

Gunnery Sgt. Scott Nichols, 36, is still a member of the MWSS 472, which is part of Marine Wing Support Group 47 of the 3rd Marine Aircraft Wing, and was not surprised when his unit was one of the first reserve units to be called up.

Nichols served in Iraq from August 2004 to February 2005. He was stationed at Al-Asad Airfield in northwestern Iraq. What Nichols mostly did, he said, was work, eat and sleep.

His unit worked 12- to 14-hour days, seven days a week. Nichols didn’t get off the base much, but said there were attacks at least once or twice a month the whole time he was in Iraq.

Advertisement

Nichols said he and his fellow soldiers were so busy they didn’t often talk about the mission. In their down time, they e-mailed family and friends, watched movies and played video games.

“I won’t lie, I didn’t have any truly horrifying experiences,” he said.

Nichols is a Sanford police officer, who joined the Army right out of high school. He then became a Marine and was on active duty for five years before joining the reserves.

Nichols knows he could be called back to Iraq any time, but said he’s lucky to be in the Marine Corps because soldiers are only deployed for seven months at a time.

Sgt. Curtis Mills

Sgt. Curtis Mills, 34, served with the 94th Military Police unit, which is based in Londonderry, N.H. He had already been activated twice before being sent to Iraq in April 2003.

Advertisement

It was still very early in the war when Mills and his unit arrived. He remembers sleeping on the ground and often eating with locals. The 94th was sent on missions all over Iraq, Mills said, from Baghdad to Fallujah to western Iraq, near the Syrian border.

Mills was on night patrol on Sept. 22, 2003, when he was nearly killed by a roadside bomb. The bomb tore open his spine, ruptured his right leg and caused a compound fracture of his right arm.

He said by the time he was injured, U.S. troops were well aware of the roadside bombs being planted by insurgents.

“We were attacked many times. I guess it was just my turn to be unlucky,” Mills said.

Mills was hospitalized for more than a year, and still has shrapnel in his shoulder. Although Mills is now on full disability and out of the military due to the injuries he suffered from the bombing, he said most of the interaction he had with Iraqi civilians was positive.

Staff Writer Robert Lowell also contributed to this report.

When the Iraq War started in March of 2003, yellow ribbons were a ubiquitous sight all across Maine and the nation. Capt. Christopher Scott Cash, who grew up in Old Orchard Beach and was a member of the 82nd Air Borne, was killed while on duty in Iraq on June 24, 2004. Staff Sgt. Jason Dube was deployed to Iraq with the 262 Engineering Company. He was there from March of 2004 to March of 2005. Here he is surrounded by a group of Iraqi children.Sgt. Larry Roukey, of Westbrook, joined the Army Reserves after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. He was killed on April 26, 2004, six weeks after being deployed to Iraq. Sgt. Scott Nichols, of Waterboro, was welcomed home from Iraq in 2003 by friends and family, including his wife Lise.

Comments are no longer available on this story