5 min read

Disagreements over the role of the Conservation Commission in Scarborough government erupted in Town Hall last week, with Conservation Commission members leveling charges of improper conduct and retaliation against town officials, and the Town Council divided on whether to discuss the commission’s conduct behind closed doors.

Paul Austin, Conservation Commission chairman, has claimed the 154-unit Eastern Village development was improperly approved by the town Planning Board Feb. 19, despite serious legal and environmental issues. He also alleges that Dan Bacon, the town planner, failed to pass on the commission’s written concerns to the Planning Board.

In retaliation for the commission’s stance, Austin said, Council Chairman Jeffrey Messer is attempting to disband the commission, or at least remove Austin as chairman. Messer pushed for an executive session to discuss the “performance of the Conservation Commission” at last week’s council meeting, but failed to get the required 5-2 majority to do so.

The March 5 meeting ended with some councilors saying Messer had left them in the dark, while he apparently discussed the situation in advance with the other three.

Austin charged that the council could not legally enter into a nonpublic session at all because he, the party who was going to be discussed, had requested a public meeting in writing.

Messer said the Town Council could go into executive session to discuss a personnel matter, specifically the Conservation Commission.

Advertisement

In an interview after the meeting, Austin argued that Conservation Commission members were not employed by the town, and therefore would not qualify as a personnel matter.

The Conservation Commission is a seven-member appointed body charged with increasing public awareness of the town’s natural resources and serving in an advisory capacity to the town Planning Board and other government bodies.

In an e-mail to The Current early Tuesday morning, Messer didn’t specify that he wanted to disband the commission, but he wrote, “I’ve come to the conclusion that the actions of some members of the Conservation Commission have caused conflict with the Planning Board and Planning Department.

“This conflict can’t continue as it is damaging to the town,” he wrote. “The purpose of the executive session was to give all councilors the same information so that we could collectively discuss how to solve this conflict. The Town Council decided not to go into executive session, which is unfortunate because a problem clearly exists that needs our attention.”

Messer said he had “shared some information” with the councilors via e-mail and “have advised them it is up to them to decide how to proceed further with this issue (if at all).”

Councilor Michael Wood said Tuesday morning that, while he doesn’t think the commission should be disbanded, some Conservation Commission members should consider whether they had been acting as members of an advisory commission or individual environmental advocates in their dealings with the Planning Board.

Advertisement

Meanwhile, Bacon and Town Manager Ron Owens met with the Conservation Commission Monday night to “go over the roles and the responsibilities of the Conservation Commission and the fact that they’re an advisory panel to the Planning Board,” Bacon said Tuesday morning.

“They need to separate citizen advocacy from the Conservation Commission role,” he said. He added that the meeting “went fine.”

Bacon and Owens have strongly denied that they edited Conservation Commission comments and other allegations leveled by Austin.

They say the Planning Board acted properly in approving the application for the new development, which will be located between Black Point Road and Commerce Drive, and that the Conservation Commission’s concerns were listened to, although not necessarily acted on the way the commission had hoped.

Owens said the apparent problems were a “classic case of miscommunication.”

“The actions of the Planning Board and the planning staff were all done in accordance with what the ordinances say and what’s customarily done in permitting any project,” he said.

Advertisement

Austin, however, alleges a lot more than “miscommunication.”

“All relations between the Conservation Commission and the town manager and the town planner and probably the Town Council have entirely broken down,” he said late last week. “We (the Conservation Commission) have members, but for all intents and purposes we have no relationship with the town.” He also called the council a “kangaroo court.”

At last Wednesday’s meeting, councilors Sylvia Most, Carol Rancourt and Judith Roy said Messer gave them only a last-minute heads-up right before the meeting that he planned to examine the Conservation Commission’s conduct behind closed doors.

Councilors Ronald Ahlquist, Richard Sullivan and Michael Wood, they charge, had evidently been in the loop for some time.

“I don’t know what (the issue) is from shinola,” Roy said at the meeting.

Most said Messer had called her home phone only the day of the council meeting and left a message, although he was fully aware that she was working and she could easily be reached on her cellular phone. She said a member of the Conservation Commission alerted her about the planned executive session.

Advertisement

“Three members of the council were completely in the dark,” she said. “I’m really frustrated with the fact that something that is important enough … (to warrant an executive session) was kept from members of council.”

Rancourt said she would walk out if council voted to enter into an executive session.

The fireworks has apparently been some time in the making, as Austin said Conservation Commission members were given the cold shoulder by town staff and the Planning Board when they raised several serious concerns about Eastern Village beginning in January.

The concerns included that Eastern Village had been granted a Department of Environmental Protection waiver to discharge storm water directly into Scarborough Marsh, which could be environmentally harmful to the marsh and to neighbors already plagued by flooding, Austin said, and that several easements the developer claimed to have were not legally valid.

“We have never been opposed to this development. Our issue is that we want to protect the marsh,” he said.

He said he believes the Planning Board should have tabled the matter until the legal issues could be resolved; instead, “the whole thing was just pushed right through.”

Advertisement

Bacon said, “Nothing was done differently in this process than in any other subdivision.”

“We listened to everyone. We opened the meeting up to public comment, which we did not have to do, and we addressed each and every one of their issues during the course of the meeting,” Planning Board Chairman Allen Paul said Monday evening.

Wood says he believes the council will continue to discuss the role of the commission – and its members – at future meetings.

“I think most likely it’s going to be back,” he said. “I think it deserves to be discussed.”

Comments are no longer available on this story