3 min read

Testing, like God and motherhood, is an American icon. We test for everything from school placement to sex appeal. But tests do not always predict actions or future behavior. The driver road test of the elderly is a case in point. Road testing is essentially worthless in revealing accident potential.

There are many reasons why an elderly driver may cause an accident, but lack of ability to pass a road test is rarely one of these. Judgment, experience, emotion, attitude, caution, health – all of which are far more important than the ability to parallel park – cannot be reliably measured by road testing.

Maine used to require a road rest bi-annually for those over 75. A detailed review of the program about 25 years ago revealed that only a tiny fraction of 1 percent of those tested were taken off the road. Further research revealed that some drivers who are unsafe at night or in heavy city traffic were capable in daytime or country driving. Based on this research, routine elderly tests were discarded. Instead, a system was adopted in which a “responsible” person (e.g., a law enforcement officer, an adult relative or even a neighbor) could report an unsafe elderly driver to the Motor Vehicle Division. The driver in question could then be scheduled for an individual evaluation – and examiners were authorized to issue licenses restricted by time and location.

Since that time there has been no statistically significant differences reported in elderly accident rates in Maine. (In fact, there has been a slight reduction, but this has probably resulted from improvement in highway and auto safety). Based on the accident rate, it seems fair to say that we have been able to accomplish the same results with less pain, less bureaucracy and less cost.

To say that elderly drivers were pleased is to understate. Road tests were uniformly hated and feared by the victims. In many cases the testees really were “victims.” The following true story illustrates. An 86-year-old woman with an excellent driving record failed her first regular road test and then failed a retest with a supervisor. A review of the case and an interview by a senior official revealed that her first road test had been scheduled only one day after she had left the hospital with a mastectomy. (She had been afraid to ask for a different date for fear it would prejudice her test.) As might be expected, she failed. By the time the second test with a supervisor came along, she was a nervous, fearful wreck. As she said, “The young man was very courteous, but between his uniform and my fear I was so distraught that, I hate to admit it, but I wet myself.” She failed again.

Few of us – at any age – would do well in a similar situation.

Advertisement

She lived about two miles from a grocery and doctor and needed to drive only one day a week on the same road. Upon observing her driving on this route, she was found easily capable in daylight hours. She was issued a limited license.

The personal-life needs of each one of us should be a part of the recipe with which government cooks. The privilege of operating a motor vehicle is not a right, but it is often a necessity. To lose a license is to lose much of one’s freedom. For those approaching discard it is one more nail in the closing door of life.

A wait-beyond-all-doubt at a stop sign or a failure to hasten through a fading green light can surely be annoying to one who is blocked behind and forced to wait. But such caution is hardly cause for accident. To watch a senior citizen take a few minutes before exiting the parking lot should be a chance for the pilgrim trapped behind to review his or her own blessings. “There, but for the grace of God, go I.”

There is no doubt that the accident rate increases after middle age, but the solution is not regular road tests. If regular road tests did, in fact reduce accidents, we should annually retest the group with the highest accident rate – drivers under 25.

Rodney Quinn, who lives in Gorham, is a former Maine secretary of state. He can be reached at rquinn@maine.rr.com. His book, “Gorham During the Great Depression,” can be purchased at the Baxter Memorial Library. Proceeds benefit the library.

Comments are no longer available on this story