4 min read

An open South Portland Planning Board seat is drawing an unusual number of applicants and prompting scrutiny from past critics of the board.

Five people have applied for the post that Craig Babbidge held for eight years, but quit while being held in jail on a probation violation.

They include an engineer, accountant, attorney and two long-time residents who’ve served on other city boards.

Babbidge, who has been jailed since Dec. 21, is serving a 75-day sentence on a probation violation relating to a 2006 arrest for drunk driving and criminal speeding. Officials speculate that publicity about Babbidge’s arrest and the vacant seat led to more interest than usual in the volunteer job.

Meanwhile, critics who complained in the past about the board’s makeup, as well as Babbidge’s ties to a local construction company, say they are closely watching the City Council’s process for appointing a new member to the seven-member board.

“Typically, the Planning Board has not been well balanced,” said Richard Rottkov, president of the South Portland Land Trust. “The majority of board members have been supportive of development, without trying to balance the needs of the community.”

Advertisement

“This seat is important because the city is at a crossroads in terms of development,” added Rosemarie DeAngelis, a former City Councilor who voted against Babbidge’s reappointment in 2005.

“With the pace of development in South Portland, we have less and less available space,” she said. “We run the risk of losing our identity, of losing what we are, which is a community of neighborhoods.”

In 2005, DeAngelis was among a minority of City Council members to vote against Councilor Maxine Beecher’s nomination of Babbidge to the post for a third term. DeAngelis was concerned that his job as project manager for Maietta Construction posed a conflict of interest, because of the volume of work the local company does with developers.

“I don’t have anything against the Maiettas,” DeAngelis said this week. “But I did have concerns about Craig voting on projects from companies that Maietta Construction was working for. To my knowledge, he never withheld a vote.”

Concerns about Babbidge intensified after he was seen accepting a check during a 2006 Planning Board meeting from developer Richard Berman. Members of the public watching the meeting complained. Babbidge explained later that the $29,500 payment was for Maietta’s work on the Brick Hill subdivision. A final phase of the project was up for approval at that meeting.

Mary Kahl, the city attorney, cleared Babbidge of any wrongdoing, saying the work would only pose a conflict if an individual member directly benefited. At a subsequent Planning Board meeting, Babbidge offered to recuse himself from voting on the project, but members agreed to allow him to continue deliberations.

Advertisement

“I don’t think they should put anyone back on that board who’s tied up with Maietta Construction,” said Bill Laidley, a past member and former chairman of the Planning Board. “There should be plenty of people who can fill the post,” he said. “The city needs a board member who can attend all the meetings, listen objectively and interpret statutes.

“There also needs to be a balance of people, which makes for a good discussion,” Laidley said. “Some people never saw a bad development, and that’s not appropriate.”

Beecher is expected to nominate a resident from District 4 after interviewing the applicants. It will be up to the seven-member City Council to approve the nominee.

The new member would serve the remainder of Babbidge’s term, which ends in April. But that person likely would be re-appointed to the post in 2008 to a three-year term. The applicants are:

• Dan Fortin, a former member of the Board of Appeals. Fortin also was an outspoken supporter of efforts to hang yellow ribbons around the city, although the displays violated a local ordinance.

•Steve Jocher, an environmental, health, safety and security manager at CYRO Industries. Jocher previously was an industrial engineer with GTE Sylvania/First Technology in Standish. He is a board member at the South Portland Land Trust and sits on the University of Southern Maine School of Applied Science Advisory Board.

• John Hatch, a litigator with Pierce Atwood in Portland. He and his wife moved to Maine from New Hampshire 21?2 years ago.

• Don Legere, former School Board member. Legere works at Haven’s Candies and previously owned Blake, Hall and Sprague Insurance Agency. He served on the Recreation/Athletic Facilities Committee, which had a role in developing the community center and Wainwright Field. He is a past president of the South Portland-Cape Elizabeth Chamber of Commerce.

• Accountant Suzi Tracy, finance director with VNA Home Health Care. She also owns a tanning salon called Local Acapulco.

Comments are no longer available on this story