Mental-health care providers who treat the state’s Medicaid patients are facing tough budget times and things are only expected to get worse as the state grapples with ways to fill a $95 million hole in revenue collections.
Mental health services, including treatment for drug abuse, already were scheduled for a $33 million cut in requested funding from the state for this biennium. That adds up to more than a $100 million in cuts because for every state dollar spent on Medicaid, the federal government sends two.
While those cuts were protested at emotional hearings before the Legislature earlier this year, they were adopted in order to close a gap in the state budget. Now, more cuts are likely as the state’s revenue picture deteriorates.
“This year’s going to be really hard,” said Carol Carothers, executive director for the National Alliance on Mental Illness of Maine, referring to cuts that are just now going into effect and those yet to come. “I just hope the cuts will be equitable,” she said, when the state moves to fill the $95 million hole it now faces, because she doesn’t believe they were equitable before.
“There wasn’t any other illness where $100 million came out of treatment,” she said, and that’s in a state where “suicide is the second leading cause of death for young people and mental illness is one of the top reasons for hospitalization of children in Maine.”
The cuts in mental health were part of an overall directive to flat-fund the state’s Medicaid program for 2008 and 2009. The Medicaid budget is about $2 billion a year, of which $610 million is funded by the state.
The cuts came out of two general areas. One involves setting standard rates for service providers, who are charging different fees for the same service. The state cut $5 million out of the budget in this current fiscal year and another $14 million in fiscal year 2009 under the rate-standardization proposal.
A form of managed care is also being adopted where an outside contractor will monitor what mental health services patients use and determine if they are getting the right care. That initiative was budgeted to save $6 million this fiscal year and $8 million next.
Retired Judge Daniel Wathen, who was appointed court master to oversee the mental health consent decree signed by the state in 1990, questions the managed care plan in court papers filed earlier this month. He argues the Department of Health and Human Services did not coordinate the managed care contract to align with the requirements outlined in the consent decree. That decree was set up to address mental health care in the state in response to a class-action lawsuit brought by patients at what was then called the Augusta Mental Health Institute.
“The department seeks to partition patient care activities between the contractor and the department, with only the department obliged to support and pursue the performance standards of the comprehensive plan. Such an illogical and complicated division of responsibility and accountability can only impede the effort to improve coordination and continuity of care,” he wrote.
Ron Welch, director of mental health for the department, said amended language on the contract already has been submitted to address Wathen’s concerns.
Welch, who used to represent mental health care providers as director of the Maine Association of Mental Health Services, said on a broader scale he understands the concerns about cuts in the Medicaid budget.
“It’s a different world than it has been in the past. The number of agencies and the amount of administrative overhead will inevitably change. We hope that the community service network offers a framework in which that can happen,” Welch said.
There already have been mergers of providers and cuts in staff. More are expected.
Sen. Joe Brannigan, D-Cumberland County, is chairman of the Legislature’s Health and Human Services Committee and director of Shalom House in Portland, which serves people with serious mental illness. He has seen the cuts at his own agency and heard of the impact in other organizations.
“I’ve heard people are shutting down some services and curtailing others. It’s very difficult to make a go of this work,” Brannigan said. “There’s holes in the budget that we put together before and now there’s this new drop in income to the state. We fear that we’re the target because there’s not a lot of interest in taking money out of education.”
An estimated 80 percent of the $6.3 billion biennial state budget goes for education and health care, and so future cuts needed to make up the $95 million revenue shortfall identified last month will likely include Medicaid.
“He can’t solve the problem without looking at health care and education,” said Carothers about Gov. John Baldacci’s options to balance the budget. But when cuts are made in mental health care, “there should be an evaluation to see if we actually save money for the state,” or simply shift costs to other providers, like jails and hospital emergency rooms, she said.
Comments are no longer available on this story