3 min read

Though plans to replace the sidewalks in Dunstan have been in the works for half a decade, some Scarborough town councilors anticipate the project will face opposition from residents at a public hearing Wednesday.

Tom Gorrill, of Gorrill-Palmer Consulting Engineers, presented councilors on Dec. 5, a plan to replace the sidewalks along Route 1 from Broadturn Road to Queens Drive and create an esplanade, making the neighborhood easier and safer to traverse by foot. Though councilors unanimously approved the first reading, in discussion, some members were skeptical about spending nearly $1 million on the project.

“This is a pretty tall expenditure,” said Councilor Ron Ahlquist. He and Councilor Richard Sullivan were concerned that there aren’t enough businesses in the area that create foot traffic to justify the price of the sidewalks. Though $500,000 was set aside in a budget a few years back to pay for the project, the rest of the cost has yet to be budgeted.

Councilor Sylvia Most said she supported the project because of the role it plays in the broader picture for changing Dunstan.

“We just finished rezoning this area. We’re anticipating more village-style development,” she said. “The pieces are coming together now, and this is a part of the package.”

The new town and village center districts that were implemented in both Oak Hill and Dunstan are meant to bring in more small businesses, housing and walkways. The zoning would require that buildings be two-stories high, allow them to be closer to the street and prevent larger box stores from being built in the area altogether.

Advertisement

Sullivan questioned why the project was not going to referendum, like most projects that cost the taxpayers more than $400,000. Town Manager Ron Owens explained that it is considered a street and sidewalk utility project, which is exempt from that rule.

“I’m sure I’m going to hear from people who have a problem with the mounting cost of it,” Sullivan said. “I’m sure of it.”

The exact cost is still up in the air – another point of contention with some councilors. Gorrill said the estimated cost is $858,000, before considering the additional expense of buying rights of way along Route 1 from some landowners in order to be able to construct the wider walkway and esplanade.

Also, the council debated the ultimate price of using the budgeted bituminous curbing, as opposed to the sturdier but more expensive granite curbing. Councilor Carol Rancourt, who said the bituminous curbing in front of her own home had been demolished by a snow plow, wondered if shying away from the granite would be “penny-wise and pound-foolish.”

Chairman Jeff Messer reminded the council that it was still early in the process and that the details would be fully fleshed out as soon as the project got moving.

Though councilors were still concerned residents that wouldn’t directly benefit from the sidewalks would not be in support of the project, Owens said it is part of the plan to redevelop that area and that the sentiment of people who live in that neighborhood would carry more weight than other residents opposed to spending the money.

Most reminded the council that while the public hearing might bring out opposition from other parts of town, the input that the council has already received from the residents of the area should be kept in mind.

This summer, the town held two neighborhood meetings with staff and officials to answer questions and consider criticisms about the proposed sidewalk project from the people who live and work in Dunstan. Owens has said that the feedback from those meetings was positive.

Comments are no longer available on this story