3 min read

A $56 million school bond proposal may have gotten a drubbing at the polls Nov. 6. But the clear defeat did not satisfy some South Portland voters, who showed up at a school committee meeting to reiterate objections to the high school renovation project.

“To me, (this plan) looked like a Cadillac when we in this city can only afford a Chevy,” resident Dave Gaudreau told the Secondary Schools Committee during a Nov. 8 meeting at the high school library.

“The plan was the biggest boondoggle. It was a farce,” said resident Dick Campbell, a retiree.

At issue was a proposed $56 million borrowing plan for rebuilding the city’s only high school. The plan, which voters defeated by a margin of 3-1, called for a major renovation and expansion of the high school off Highland Avenue.

Some residents complained that specific parts of the projects were unnecessary – such as a second gym, moving the tennis courts and developing a field with artificial turf.

Many residents who spoke said they would have voted for a less costly plan with fewer amenities.

Advertisement

“If the price had been $30 million, I would have supported it,” said Gaudreau, who described himself as a South Portland native.

“I’m all for replacing the windows, upgrading the heating, removing the asbestos,” he said, noting some of the significant problems identified with the aging school buildings.

The residents spoke during a public comment period after the Secondary Schools Facilities Committee discussed immediate needs for repairs at the high school.

“We’ve got to do the essentials and our city leaders need to come up with the plan,” Gaudreau said, echoing statements by other residents.

Although some residents showed anger and disappointment, committee members said later the comments were helpful.

Assistant Superintendent Steve Bailey, who facilitates the committee, said he was pleased that “folks were willing to express their own frustrations with the ballot question and provide some of their own insights on what is needed for voters to accept the school building project.”

Advertisement

The committee plans to keep collecting information before making its next move. No decisions are expected until early next year.

Bailey asked residents for specific complaints and suggestions. Campbell, who shouted during the meeting, was asked by Bailey to identify his concerns.

Campbell criticized the committee for failing to provide line items on project costs and for not choosing the lowest bid for the construction project.

He also complained about the costs taxpayers must bear to make the high school accessible to people with handicaps.

Other residents offered advice to the committee, saying they supported the idea of fixing problems at the high school and improving education there.

Paul Connolly, a South Portland resident for 32 years, told the committee that it is the job of the school board and city council to prioritize the building needs at the high school and to come up with a price that taxpayers can afford.

Advertisement

“You people need to put this in the hands of the board of education and city council,” he said. “It is up to them to figure out the things that have to be done and how to finance it.”

Other residents expressed concern about the number of building projects under discussion in South Portland – including plans for rebuilding the middle schools and renovating the armory as a new City Hall.

“None of you should hang your heads,” resident Fred Bowring told the committee, composed of school officials, city leaders and residents.

“The cards were stacked against you,” he said, noting the rise in property taxes and public worries about city spending.

Susan Adams, a member of SPHS-YES!, was the only resident to stand up and express support for the newly defeated school bond.

Adams is among a handful of parents who formed a political action committee to campaign for the bond’s passage.

Updating the high school “needs to be the No. 1 priority for the city,” Adams said.

“Every leader in the city should be involved in this,” she said. “If we don’t have people in government backing us, it’s pointless to start over.”

Comments are no longer available on this story