A little more than a year after two people listed on the state’s sex- offender registry were murdered on Easter Sunday, the Legislature will begin the difficult task of working to improve the state’s sex-offender laws.
Legislators will be looking for answers to a number of difficult questions: How much information should the state’s online sex-offender registry give about those listed on it? Who should be listed on it? And, where should they be allowed to live?
One of the most important problems for lawmakers to address is the way the registry treats dangerous offenders versus those considered least likely to re-offend. An adult who is convicted of molesting a child, for example, is listed alongside an 18-year-old convicted of having sex with a girlfriend who is two years younger. While most people would consider the former to be a threat to young children, few would consider the latter a danger.
The state needs to find a way to differentiate between the two types of offenders in the information it provides to the public and re-evaluate whether least-dangerous offenders deserve to be lumped in with the most dangerous.
The debate over restricting where offenders can live comes after Joseph Tellier moved from community to community in York County last year. In each new home, Tellier’s presence was met with protests.
To be sure, Tellier is someone few people would be comfortable living next to. He served 15 years in prison after being convicted of kidnapping and sexually assaulting a 10-year-old girl. However, the saga of what seemed to be a never-ending relocation process made it clear how inadequate the state’s laws are and how much of a challenge officials at the Department of Corrections face in finding permanent homes for the state’s most dangerous sex offenders.
Several communities responded by passing ordinances restricting where sex offenders could live. Those ordinances are a poor solution to the problem. If every community were to adopt a different ordinance, it would create an endlessly complex web of local ordinances that would be nearly impossible to navigate.
It remains unclear whether any of these ordinances will stand up to a challenge in court, and, as Sen. Bill Diamond, the chairman of the Criminal Justice Committee, has pointed out, these ordinances don’t address what sex offenders do – only where they live. An ordinance, for example, might keep sex offenders from living within 200 feet of a school, but it does not keep them from hanging out there.
Keeping in mind that sex offenders who have served their time need to live somewhere, the Legislature needs to come up with some clear guidelines that help ensure public safety and adhere to the Constitutional rights of individuals. These guidelines should apply only to the most dangerous sex offenders. While legislators are considering these restrictions, they should also consider some strict penalties for people who abuse the sex-offender registry, using it to harass and harm those listed on it.
These people are not only abusing people who have served their time, but they are also abusing a system the public has put in place to ensure its safety.
Brendan Moran, editor
Comments are no longer available on this story