4 min read

“Paying the price on Route 1,” Karen Vachon’s interesting essay in this paper a couple of weeks ago has, understandably, gotten me thinking about economic development along Route 1 and what it is going on along that busy road.

That’s my job, anyway, but sometimes you need a little jolt to get back on track and bring things into focus. Economic development is not a field that brings instant gratification. If patience is a virtue, then most of us in this field have earned our place in heaven. That aside, my relief I am feeling for my eternal future not withstanding, I think this is a good time to talk a bit about what drives economic development and then look at Route 1 in particular.

It’s not driven by altruism

Economic development is driven by the desire and a need to make a profit. Considering that not all profit-driven enterprises make altruism and the public good their first motives, communities, at least those communities thinking ahead, develop plans, laws and ordinances to control economic growth in a positive way. In the best of circumstances, this creates a viable partnership between the public and private sector that benefits both. In the worst-case scenario, one side benefits to the detriment of the other side.

In the 2006 Update of Scarborough’s Comprehensive Plan, Section 6, Patterns of Commercial Development, several areas are listed as commercial centers. They are:

•Small neighborhood-oriented retail areas at Dunstan Corner, North Scarborough, and Pine Point;

Advertisement

•A larger community retail and service center at Oak Hill;

•Regional retailers and offices spreading south of the Maine Mall along the turnpike and Payne Road; and

•A mixture of business serving Scarborough residents, residents of the region and travelers along Route 1.

It is this last area that interests Karen Vachon, me and, I hope, everyone else in Scarborough.

In 2002-2003, Scarborough embarked on a “visioning” process. More than 250 residents took part in a set of discussions looking to the future. One of the results of this process was the concept: “We will create a Main Street that is safe, sociable, and attractive for residents to work, shop, and visit. To maintain our diverse tax base, at least a quarter of new development will be business and commercial. New businesses will range from biomedical research labs to fishing and from corporate headquarters to high quality arts and retail…”

Scarborough is getting there, slowly but surely, in a planned, organized fashion. Riding along Route, I think it’s impossible not to notice where we have come. Since the 1994 Comprehensive Plan, there has been a remarkable change along Route 1: the Maine Medical Center campus including their state-of-the-art research institute, the Mercedes Benz and Land Rover/Jaguar dealerships, Little Dolphin Marketplace, the Allied Home Mortgage Building, Nonesuch River Plaza, the Enterprise Business Park and Lois’ Natural Foods.

Advertisement

There are also several new and rehabilitated complexes with retail and/or office space, including Scarborough Village Square on the site of the now empty Orion Center, an aesthetically pleasing office condominium project at 383 U.S. Route 1 (the site of the old Moosehead Motel), and Bessey Square, a groundbreaking (no pun intended) retail, office and residential complex next to the soon-to-be started elderly housing project in the Bessey School. (My apologies to all the projects that I missed, but this esteemed publication only gives me so much space).

What the town doesn’t have control over is the time it takes for a project to get going. There is a long period from the inception of a project, acquiring property, permitting on the local, state and often federal levels, acquiring financing and tenants, to construction and completion. Many of the projects cited in Karen’s article are fully permitted and will begin construction or reconstruction shortly.

To return to an important point mentioned earlier, economic development on the private side of the ledger is driven by profit. The things that make Scarborough attractive to developers are location, demographics and aesthetics. The unfortunate part of this equation is that it drives up real estate prices. If a developer has to pay more to acquire property, the cost goes up. There has been a confidence that Scarborough is worth the investment, because the potential for profit is there.

On the town side, and that includes the residents, the advantages of high-quality development are reflected in a continuing improvement in the aesthetics of Route 1 and, equally as important, a positive effect on the tax rate. Scarborough’s insistence on high-quality commercial development has helped Scarborough achieve the lowest tax rate in Greater Portland.

There is a downside to this growth and demand, as Karen points out. As the desirability and demand for commercial property increases, it is going to be harder for many small and marginal businesses to afford Route 1. It is imperative that we work to make these small businesses competitive and profitable so that they don’t disappear.

I believe that this is one of most pressing challenges facing economic developers and community leaders today. My hope is that we will find the answers so that all types of desirable businesses will prosper here.

Harvey Rosenfeld is president of the Scarborough Economic Development Corp.

Comments are no longer available on this story