4 min read

The drowning of a 3-year-old boy at a Westbrook day-care center was the result of neglect and inattention by center staff, an investigation by the state has determined. The day-care center could be faced with a penalty as severe as losing its license.

The Maine Department of Health and Human Services also found Koala Child Kare and Learning Center in violation of licensing rules. Westbrook police, meanwhile, have decided not to bring criminal charges in the March 26 death at Koala.

Andrew Thurston, who would have turned 4 on April 17, drowned at the Koala Child Kare and Learning Center pool on the morning of March 26. The Maine Medical Examiner’s office ruled last Tuesday that the death was an accidental drowning.

In a statement at a press conference Wednesday, Westbrook Police Chief Paul McCarthy said police received a 911 call at about 10:40 a.m. from the center reporting that a child was not breathing and was receiving CPR. Upon arrival, emergency rescue personnel found Thurston in cardiac arrest. McCarthy said he was rushed immediately to a waiting ambulance and then to Maine Medical Center, where he was pronounced dead at 11:15 a.m.

Click here for the entire text of McCarthy’s statement

Catherine Cobb, a spokeswoman for the Department of Health and Human Services, said at the press conference the drowning was the result of inattention by the child-care professional at the pool.

Advertisement

Cobb said an investigation revealed that the attendant, Patricia Lobley of Westbrook, was in charge of five children at an activity in the pool. The children, four of whom did not know how to swim, were wearing flotation devices.

According to McCarthy, after the activity, Lobley, 62, allowed the children to remove their flotation devices. The children got out of the pool to remove the flotation devices and were allowed to re-enter the pool.

Lobley, in the pool, supervised four of the children, who were allowed to jump into the pool from the deck, make their way to the ladder out and repeat the activity, McCarthy said. During that activity, Thurston walked to the other end of the pool behind Lobley and re-entered the water, holding onto a barbell flotation device. McCarthy said Lobley lost track of Thurston for several minutes, during which time he drowned. According to Cobb, Thurston was likely floating face down in the water for several minutes.

Click here for the entire text of the statement from the Department of Health and Human Services

Wednesday afternoon, Kim Cairns, the owner of Koala Child Kare, said she had not seen the police and Department of Health and Human Services report. When asked about findings of neglect, she said, “We have always followed state guidelines, and will continue to do so. This is a horrific accident, and nothing is going to bring Andrew back.”

In addition to the determination of neglect, the state has said that the center violated licensing rules. According to the center’s printed materials presented to parents, a Red Cross-certified swim instructor supervises swimming activities. While Westbrook police said Lobley holds an American Heart Association certificate for CPR, she has not held a Red Cross swim instructor certification since 1978. McCarthy said at the press conference that he believed Cairns was aware that Lobley did not have a Red Cross swim instructor certification. For that reason, the state has determined that the center misrepresented its services.

Advertisement

Cobb said the day-care center was last licensed in November. At that time, the day care submitted materials stating that it had a Red Cross certified swim instructor conducting all pool activities, which was false, as Lobley was the only instructor on staff.

The investigation by the state will continue, said Cobb, with a final determination on what violations Koala made coming as soon as the end of this week.

Potential repercussions of the violations could include a fine, a change in the status of the day-care center’s license to conditional or even a revocation of the license.

Cobb said that inspections since the incident found no other infractions by the center.

“I can’t say there are any concerns,” she said.

Following the accident last week, Koala Child Kare has remained open, although Cairns said Wednesday morning that it has been difficult for the staff to continue with business as usual. Since the incident, the pool has remained closed.

Advertisement

“It’s been devastating,” Cairns said, visibly holding her emotions in check. “Andrew was one of our babies.”

Staff Writer Robert Lowell contributed to this report.

For more on this story, see the April 5 issue of the American Journal

At the Westbrook public safety building on Wednesday, police chief Paul McCarthy and Geoffrey Green, the deputy director of Mainetement regarding the investigation of Koala Day Kare in Westbrook.Westbrook Police Chief Paul McCarthy speaks at a press conference Wednesday regarding the drowning of a child at Koala Child Kare.

Comments are no longer available on this story