7 min read

The drowning of a 3-year-old boy at a Westbrook day-care center was the result of neglect and inattention by center staff, an investigation by the state has determined.

The Maine Department of Health and Human Services also found Koala Child Kare and Learning Center in violation of licensing rules. Westbrook police, meanwhile, have decided not to bring criminal charges in the March 26 death at Koala.

The police and Maine Department of Health and Human Services released their findings Wednesday afternoon at a joint press conference at the Westbrook police department. The day-care center could be faced with a penalty as severe as losing its license.

Andrew Thurston, who would have turned 4 on April 17, drowned at the Koala Child Kare and Learning Center pool on the morning of March 26. The Maine Medical Examiner’s office ruled last Tuesday that the death was an accidental drowning.

The incident has prompted the Department of Health and Human Services to investigate what could be inadequate regulations regarding pools in the state, particularly at day-care centers. The department has begun an investigation into regulations in other states.

In a statement at the press conference, Westbrook Police Chief Paul McCarthy said police received a 911 call at about 10:40 a.m. from the center reporting that a child was not breathing and was receiving CPR. Upon arrival, emergency rescue personnel found Thurston in cardiac arrest. McCarthy said he was rushed immediately to a waiting ambulance and then to Maine Medical Center, where he was pronounced dead at 11:15 a.m.

Advertisement

The police will not pursue criminal charges, although the Maine Office of the Attorney General will be conducting an investigation into the matter, McCarthy said. Detective Sgt. Steve Lyons, who headed the investigation for Westbrook police, said he expected to send his findings to the Attorney General’s office in a couple of weeks, although he couldn’t be certain.

Catherine Cobb, a spokeswoman for the Department of Health and Human Services, said at the press conference the drowning was the result of inattention by the child-care professional at the pool.

Cobb said an investigation revealed that the attendant, Patricia Lobley of Westbrook, was in charge of five children at an activity in the pool. The children, four of whom did not know how to swim, were wearing flotation devices.

According to McCarthy, after the activity, Lobley, 62, allowed the children to remove their flotation devices. The children got out of the pool to remove the flotation devices and were allowed to re-enter the pool.

Lobley, in the pool, supervised four of the children, who were allowed to jump into the pool from the deck, make their way to the ladder out and repeat the activity, McCarthy said. During that activity, Thurston walked to the other end of the pool behind Lobley and re-entered the water, holding onto a bar-bell flotation device. McCarthy said Lobley lost track of Thurston for several minutes, during which time he drowned. According to Cobb, Thurston was likely floating face-down in the water for several minutes.

“The department has concluded that the swim instructor exercised poor judgment by allowing the children to remove their flotation devices and also failed to adequately supervise the children in her care as required by the day-care licensing rules. The owner of Koala Child Kare shares responsibility for the inadequate supervision of children in the pool. The combination of poor judgement, inattention and lack of supervision constitutes neglect,” read a statement released by the Department of Health and Human Services.

Advertisement

Cobb said at the press conference that owner Kim Cairns and Lobley would find themselves on a state database that tracks child care professionals with findings of neglect against them. That database can be accessed by all child care employers.

Wednesday afternoon, Cairns said she had not seen the police and Department of Health and Human Services report. When asked about findings of neglect, she said, “We have always followed state guidelines, and will continue to do so. This is a horrific accident, and nothing is going to bring Andrew back.”

In addition to the determination of neglect, the state has said that the center violated licensing rules. According to the center’s printed materials presented to parents, swimming activities are supervised by a Red Cross-certified swim instructor. While Westbrook police said Lobley holds an American Heart Association certificate for CPR, she has not held a Red Cross swim instructor certification since 1978. McCarthy said at the press conference that he believed Cairns was aware that Lobley did not have a Red Cross swim instructor certification. For that reason, the state has determined that the center misrepresented its services.

“It is very important that families be able to rely on the written description of the programs provided by licensed day-care centers when selecting an appropriate center for their children,” said Cobb.

Cobb said the day-care center was last licensed in November. At that time, the day care submitted materials stating that it had a Red Cross certified swim instructor conducting all pool activities, which was false, as Lobley was the only instructor on staff.

The investigation by the state will continue, said Cobb, with a final determination on what violations Koala made coming as soon as the end of this week.

Advertisement

Potential repercussions of the violations could include a fine, a change in the status of the day-care center’s license to conditional or even a revocation of the license.

Cobb said that inspections since the incident found no other infractions by the center.

“I can’t say there are any concerns,” she said.

The state has said previously that Koala has had 13 complaints against it since 1998, although some of those came before Cairns purchased the facility in 2002. One of those complaints was an unfounded claim of abuse, while the others were claims of rule violations that did not merit action by the state. In March of 1999, a 4-year-old child fell into the pool and stopped breathing, but was resuscitated by emergency health personnel.

The incident has raised questions as to whether the state should have stricter controls governing pools at day-cares. State Rep. Tim Driscoll, D-Westbrook, said this week he wants to hold a public meeting with the Department of Health and Human Services, day-care operators and other groups with swimming pools such as the YMCA to talk about water safety. Driscoll said he had a preliminary meeting with Jeff Green of the Department of Health and Human Services this week.

According to Driscoll, many day-care centers have outside pools; however, the state doesn’t know how many. Driscoll wants a database created to track that information.

Advertisement

Driscoll also said he is contemplating introducing a bill in the Legislature to look at regulating safety at swimming pools, specifically at day-care centers.

Chris Zukas-Lessard, deputy director of the Maine Center for Disease Control and Prevention, a division of the Department of Health and Human Services, said state law does not require inspection of non-residential pools in the state.

Zukas-Lessard said the Department of Health and Human Services licenses health-care facilities and eating and lodging facilities, including day-care centers. Current practice dictates that the department will inspect a pool on the premises of these facilities if it discovers a pool exists, she said.

About Koala Kare, she said, “I don’t believe that pool was inspected by the department.

Cobb reiterated that statement at the press conference, saying that at the November licensing the pool was not inspected because it was not in use while the inspectors were on the premises.

However, the department doesn’t actively seek out and keep track of all pools in the state. Zukas-Lessard said inspections cover pool facilities and equipment as well as operating practices.

Advertisement

Following the accident last week, Koala Child Kare has remained opened, although Cairns said Wednesday morning that it has been difficult for the staff to continue with business as usual. Since the incident, the pool has remained closed.

“It’s been devastating,” Cairns said, visibly holding her emotions in check. “Andrew was one of our babies.”

Children’s laughter rang throughout the halls of the center Wednesday morning as a magician performed in one of the rooms. However, Cairns’ mood revealed an undercurrent of sadness permeating the center. She said she and the employees are trying to move forward, but with difficulty.

“We’re trying,” she said.

Westbrook resident Alex Stone, parent of two children at Koala Child Kare, said in an interview prior to release of the state and police findings that he initially kept his two sons out of day care after the incident. Before bringing them back, he had a discussion with the center’s management team, which convinced him it was doing everything it could to keep the kids safe. Stone brought his two sons back last Thursday, satisfied that it was still a safe place.

“I feel comfortable,” he said. “I asked a lot of questions and I got a lot of answers, and I’m satisfied that my kids are going to be safe.”

Advertisement

Stone said he has talked to some parents who have kids at Koala, and said he wasn’t aware of any parents who had not brought their children back.

Stone said he hopes the pool reopens because “thousands” of kids have learned to swim there and are better for it. He said he thought it would be a shame if the center closed the pool, although he said he thought the center needed to make some changes as to how it operates the pool.

Cairns refrained Wednesday morning from discussing operations at the center following the accident.

Staff Writer Robert Lowell contributed to this report.

Comments are no longer available on this story