Westbrook resident Greg Theriault was in the midst of renovating his home last November when he was informed by the city that he would have to install sprinklers.
Theriault said he wasn’t told he would have to do that before receiving a building permit and beginning renovation. Putting the project on hold, he has appealed the decision, which he is hoping will be reversed at a Zoning Board of Appeals meeting on April 4.
Theriault’s conflict is having wide repercussions for city residents. The Westbrook Code Enforcement Office is changing the requirements for receiving building permits in the city.
Before, a homeowner could receive a building permit with hand-drawn renderings of all but the largest proposed projects, especially for small items such as a shed or a porch. In many cases, that will still be enough. But now, for anything such as a garage or any kind of addition, homeowners will have to submit scaled drawings for the project.
Code Enforcement Officer Rick Gouzie said this change is the continuation of an effort by his office to formalize the building permit application process. He said when he first started work in Westbrook in 2000, the office would accept hand drawings on the back of the application. However, the dispute with Theriault brought the official change.
Theriault owns a pristine, white Victorian on Tolman Street. It is separated into four apartments, one of which he and his partner, Judith Ladd, occupy. He and Ladd bought the home in the beginning of 2005 and moved in a year later. Before that, Theriault had lived in Portland for more than 20 years.
Theriault said he plans to be a live-in landlord and wants to improve the home for himself and his tenants. He currently has one vacant apartment and two tenants, both of whom are subsidized.
To improve the home, early last year Theriault presented the city with plans to add an enclosed staircase on the back and to expand a dormer on the third floor.
Hand-drawn renderings lie at the heart of the matter between Theriault and the city. According to Theriault, he submitted sketches of his project and described to Gouzie in detail what he proposed to do. He was then issued a building permit. Gouzie said what Theriault drew and described was not as extensive as what he built, although Theriault said the project in process was actually less extensive than what he described to Gouzie.
Regardless, Theriault was four or so months into his renovation when Westbrook Fire Inspector Chuck Jarrett visited the home and decided that Theriault would have to install sprinklers. Jarrett learned of the work at Theriault’s home after Theriault called the fire department one night during an intense rainstorm, seeking help because of water leaking down through the area of the house being renovated.
Jarrett issued Theriault a code violation on Nov. 22. On Nov. 30, Jarrett issued a letter to the city stating that detailed, scaled drawings must be submitted with a request for a permit. That letter was followed on Dec. 19 by a letter from the Code Enforcement office requiring the same. Both letters now hang on a wall in the code enforcement office at Westbrook City Hall to inform homeowners seeking building permits for work on their homes.
According to city code and state law, if a homeowner has renovated 25 percent or more of a multi-family building with three or more units, the homeowner is required to install sprinklers throughout the home.
Theriault is appealing Jarrett’s assessment of his home, stating that he renovated less than 25 percent of his home. For his part, Jarrett refused to comment on the matter while it is still in dispute before the Zoning Board of Appeals.
Theriault feels he’s being treated unfairly by the city and expects the cost of sprinklers throughout his home to be anywhere from $30,000 to twice that much. Gouzie said he’s seen sprinklers cost as much as $15,000 to $30,000 in the city in similar situations.
Theriault said he and Ladd have put their life savings into the house and taken out loans to renovate it, and now he’s not certain if he can get additional loan money to cover the costs of the sprinklers. He said Ladd has told him she’s not even certain she wants to stay in Westbrook because of the frustration she’s felt at the city.
“This has cost us a lot of time and money and aggravation and stress,” Theriault said.
Homeowner, city at odds over renovations
Comments are no longer available on this story