The group that first proposed a tax on bottled water aimed at Poland Springs is now circulating a new petition that would create a government board to make sure commercial bottlers don’t take too much of the coveted resource out of the ground.
That board would be funded by a fee on every gallon of water extracted for so-called non-traditional uses, but it would be considerably less than the proposed 20 cents a gallon tax pushed in a petition drive that failed in 2005.
“It’s quite a bit different from the last bill,” said Jim Wilfong of H2O for Maine, adding the “real controversial part” has been taken out. The goal now, he said, is to protect the resource.
“Currently Maine has a resource that is very valuable and extremely vulnerable because Maine’s law is weak, outmoded and inadequate,” Wilfong said. Only Maine and Texas still follow the old British rule of “absolute dominion,” which gives groundwater rights to the property owner where the well is located, he said.
Wilfong held a press conference last Thursday at the Statehouse to launch a new petition drive and also announce his organization is suing the state to enforce the water extraction law it already has on the books.
The lawyer handling that suit is former state Rep. Barbara Merrill, an independent candidate for governor last year, who said currently the state has “interpreted this law so as to render it meaningless.”
H2O for Maine says the law, if properly enforced, would block almost all removal of groundwater from Maine by bottlers unless they were grandfathered from when the law was passed and amended in the late 1980s.
Merrill said shutting down all bottling operations is not the group’s intention, but the organization wants to enforce the current law until it can be shown whether removing the water is harmful.
Howard Dearborn, who lives on Lovewell Pond in Fryeburg and believes the nearby Poland Springs well has diverted so much water it has made his pond “go stale,” spoke at the press conference and said grandfathered rights should only go so far.
“Last fall, even my well started to suck air,” Dearborn said. “You can’t take things away and magically replace them with talk or money even.”
H2O for Maine’s latest proposal would create a Freshwater Resource Board, which would be charged with monitoring the “sustainability of groundwater in Maine and protect against uses that are detrimental to aquifers, bodies of surface water or wetlands, or to the public health and safety and general welfare.”
The board’s goal would be to protect traditional water users like residents, farmers, municipalities and water districts from the effects of excessive extraction by commercial bottlers. To pay for its work, the proposed law would levy a fee on commercial bottlers of a half cent to a cent per gallon as compared to the 20 cent per gallon called for in H2O for Me’s original petition.
Wilfong said he did not have specifics on how much money it would take to keep the board in operation and pay for its regular monitoring of groundwater supplies, but estimated the cost at between $1 million and $5 million.
Wilfong said his organization started circulating petitions last week to put the proposal on the November ballot, but would rather have the Legislature adopt the proposed law.
The question on the petition reads: “Do you want to redefine rights to and uses of groundwater, and to create a new state board with broad powers to monitor and ensure the supply and quality of groundwater and impose fees on water extracted for nontraditional uses?”
Comments are no longer available on this story