The looming debt for health-insurance benefits promised to retired state employees, teachers and now municipal police and firefighters is going to be substantially higher than the $1.2 billion projected three years ago. But the full extent of the bad news won’t be known until the second week in December.
State Controller Ed Karass told the Appropriations Committee last week that actuaries hired by the state are still trying to nail down some numbers.
“I apologize to all of you for the delay,” he said, but because of inadequate data, including how much some teachers are putting into the system now, an early estimate could be off by “hundreds of millions.”
Karass did confirm the numbers would be up substantially from a 2003 estimate of $1.2 billion, but some members of the Appropriations Committee wanted to know more.
“We’re going up substantially. Double? Triple?” asked Sen. Richard Nass, R-York County.
The estimates are important because starting July 1, 2007 – the beginning of the new fiscal year – all states and some of the country’s largest municipalities will have to declare what they will have to pay out in insurance costs for retirees, as baby boomers leave the workforce and health-care costs go up.
Under a new accounting rule – known in government circles as the Government Accounting Standards Board statement number 45 or GASB 45 for short – governments have to show their so-called un-funded liability on their financial statements. While the rule can’t force states to save for the inevitable bill, if they don’t, the bonding houses that rate the quality of government bonds say it likely would affect state credit ratings. And that will make borrowing money more expensive.
“GASB 45 doesn’t force you to start setting money aside,” Karass said, but if a state doesn’t, “you will suffer a rating downgrade in the bond market.”
“We’re probably talking about a multi-billion-dollar exposure,” speculated Rep. Sawin Millett, R-Waterford, who used to be the state’s finance commissioner. He pressed Karass for an estimate on how much a new benefit – state-subsidized health insurance for retired police and firefighters – was going to cost down the road. That controversial benefit was pushed at the end of last session in what some saw as an election-year ploy.
“I can’t speak to the police and firefighters,” Karass said. “Where is the data? The data is all over the place.”
Karass promised the actuarial estimate for the liability the state faces to pay for benefits for retired state employees and school teachers would be ready by the second week in December. He said estimating the new benefit for police and firefighters would take longer, but has to be done by the start of the new fiscal year.
There currently is $81 million set aside to help pay the health-insurance bill, but substantially more will have to budgeted each year by the Legislature to build up the account over the next 30 years. Karass will be proposing what some predict will be controversial legislation to move the fund over to the state Retirement System, which handles state employee pensions, because of its track record on return on investment. He said the state’s treasury office gets around 4.5 percent interest, but the Retirement System is averaging 7.5 percent of late.
“Dave is very good, but the experience is really over in the Retirement System,” he said, referring to State Treasurer Dave Lemoine.
There currently are close to 9,000 retired state employees and 6,500 retired teachers, and another 42,000 active employees in the pipeline. The state pays up to 100 percent of premiums for retired state employees and 45 percent for teachers. Full-time police and firefighters were given a 45 percent benefit, up until the time they hit Medicare eligibility.
Comments are no longer available on this story