8 min read

Scarborough voters are being asked to approve two school construction projects on the ballot this fall, a new intermediate school and a renovation at the middle school, that would cost a total of $55 million.

Residents must decide whether completely demolishing Wentworth Intermediate and building a new school for $38.3 million and adding onto the Middle School for $16.5 million. Each project is separate on the ballot, and neither the intermediate school nor the middle school would receive state aid.

The addition for the middle school is to address capacity problems, said school officials, while the complete replacement of Wentworth is due to an old, failing building that does not meet many of the current building and safety codes.

Though in agreement that both the middle school and Wentworth have serious problems, some town councilors are questioning the sizes, costs and tax impacts of the two projects.

Magic numbers

Scarborough Town Councilor Jeff Messer said spending $55 million without any help from the state is asking too much. “We need to do something with these grade levels, I am fully supportive and on board with that, but not at $55 million,” said Messer. “It’s just wildly excessive when you compare it to just about anything.”

Advertisement

These projects arrived on the heals of the $27 million High School, added Messer, which was the most expensive town-funded project in Maine.

While Messer said he believed the schools could be built for half of the proposed cost or less, he was also upset with the brochures sent home with students and available at Town Hall that promote the two school projects. The brochures, said School Board Chairman Robert Mitchell, were paid for by the design fund for the projects, but any of the signs supporting the projects are all privately funded, he added.

“We wanted to get as much factual information out there as we could so people could make an educated decision,” said Mitchell. Mitchell said he was also adamant that the brochures should encourage people only to vote rather than endorse the projects.

The brochures have information on the tax impact of the two schools, information both Messer and Town Councilor Shawn Babine said is misleading.

To begin with, they said, though the brochures say the average home value in Scarborough is $289,000, which excludes water front property.

According to Superintendent David Doyle, water front property is left out of the average value since the relatively small amount of property skews the value of most of the homes in Scarborough. At the time the brochures were printed, said Doyle, the $289,800 was correct. Since then, he said, the value has been updated for 2006.

Advertisement

Town Assessor Paul Lesperance said that for 2006 the average home value without including waterfront property is $303,400. With waterfront property added in, it increases to $371,600.

Based on information given to the council, said Messer, he did his own calculations. For every year from 2008 to 2013, Messer totaled the yearly payments of the schools and divided that number by the entire town’s assessed value, which he increased by $60 million to take into account the average increase.

With that method, said Messer, the tax rate for 2012, the year with the highest payment, comes out to $1.33 for every $1,000 in assessed value, or $130 for every $100,000 in assessed value. His number for the tax impact in that year comes to $495.30 for an average home, while the brochure numbers list the peak year as 2011 with an impact of $49.51.

“Those brochures, and I hate to put it in these terms, are intentionally misleading,” said Messer.

“This is an analysis that can change from person to person,” said Babine, who also did his own calculations of the tax impact. “People’s analyses are not necessarily wrong.” While Babine said he is not suggesting his numbers are absolutely right, they are close to Messer’s calculations. The process is essentially the same, though where Messer used a 2 percent increase in the town’s valuation, about $60 million, Babine used $30 million. Also, said Babine, he rounded numbers to make it easier to handle.

What he created, said Babine, may not be 100 percent accurate, but it gives a range of numbers anyone can easily understand.

Advertisement

Babine’s impacts also showed 2012 to be the year of highest payment at $401, about $100 less than Messer’s calculations.”I think the brochure information is misleading,” said Babine.

According to Mitchell and Doyle, the way the tax impact information for the brochures was calculated also took into account town debt that will be paid off over the years.

“You can do a lot with numbers,” said Mitchell. “You can make them speak however you want. The school board or the building committee did not do a thing. We got all of our information from the town. There’s nothing magic about it.”

Size questioned

Messer also questioned whether or not the square footage per student in the two schools is necessary based on current enrollment and projections listed in the comprehensive plan.

In the middle school the total square footage will be 174,954, which is 181 square feet per student with 968 students and 159 square feet based on 1,100 students, the highest number listed in the brochures.

Advertisement

For Wentworth the total square footage will be 184,794, which is 193 square feet based on 920 students and 168 square feet based on 1,508 students.

The comprehensive plan, which guides the town’s growth, said Messer, lists the highest year of projected enrollment for third through fifth grade at 794 in 2007. For sixth through eighth grades, the highest number is 850 for 2010.

Referencing a report to the state Board of Education by the Office of School Facilities, Messer said the state recommends 135 square feet per student for middle schools and 125 square feet for intermediate schools.

However, Mitchell said all of the new classrooms in both schools will be 800 square feet, which meets the states recommendations. He added that dividing the total square footage by students adds in large spaces such as the gyms and cafeterias that aren’t strictly instructional and are in some cases for community use. The high student numbers on the brochures, said Mitchell, are the maximums the buildings could hold.

In Wentworth, 7,457 square feet is dedicated for district-wide use including testing, food service and storage. The gym at Wentworth has been used by community services, and that will continue, said Mitchell.

“I’m not disputing that these two buildings are large,” said Mitchell. “I make no bones about it. These projects aren’t cheap, but my view is that if you’re going to spend money you might as well get quality. The last thing you want to do is eight years after it’s built realize it isn’t big enough. We have living proof of that with the middle school.”

Advertisement

Though Mitchell said enrollment has slowly declined over the last four years, Scarborough schools topped 3,300 kids.

According to Doyle, this year the kindergarten class is the biggest in Scarborough’s history at 252 kids. The current fifth grade, he added, has 282 kids but began with 220.

“Quite frankly, I’d rather create a space that is adequate rather than kick ourselves in five years like we did with the middle school,” said Doyle. “I don’t want to have any more building projects.”

When the middle school was built, said Doyle, the town knew it would be much too small. At that time the state was paying for the majority of the building and would allow for only a five year enrollment projection. Now, said Doyle, the school built for 600 kids is struggling to accomodate 900. There are also 15 portable classrooms around the middle school in an attempt to handle the overflow.

“Beyond the obvious modular classroom situation, the facility isn’t designed for that many kids,” said Doyle.

Laundry list of problems

Advertisement

For Wentworth, said Doyle, the list of problems is even longer. “It’s a tired building,” said Doyle. “It’s served the community well, but it’s time.”

Wentworth was originally built in 1962 for junior high students and currently has 785 students from third to fifth grade. Doyle listed problems such as an outdated heating system, poor air quality, leaking windows, lack of insulation, no sprinkler system and trenches below the school for pipes and wires that flood, carrying water beneath the floors.

According to Rob Klinedinst of Harriman Associates, the architects who designed the proposed buildings, the school lacks a sprinkler system, the roof is not up to snow load bearing codes, the playground is not handicap accessible and the parking along both sides of the driveway is unsafe.

Also, said Klinedinst at an Oct. 17 public hearing on the school projects, using the facility condition index, a comparison used in the industry that weighs renovation costs against replacement costs, Harriman Associates determined it would be better to replace the school. Normally, an index greater than 65 percent indicates that a building should be replaced. The evaluation for Wentworth came to 88 percent.

To renovate, said Klinedinst, the work required would cost about $33.6 million while a new school will cost about $38.3 million.

By building a new school, he added, the town does not have to deal with the cost and problems of relocating all the students during the renovations.

Advertisement

At the public hearing a number of teachers and parents spoke about the problems with teaching in modular classrooms, the fluctuating temperatures and safety concerns.

“What I’m concerned about are the parts of Wentworth that you can’t see that affect the health and safety of the kids, teachers and administrators,” said Pam Joy, who has two children in Wentworth. “We need to make sure they are in a school environment that’s as safe and healthy as possible.”

Beth Libby, a teacher, said kids regularly wear their coats in the classrooms. She also questioned whether having multiple entrances to the school is safe.

Also, said Libby, the school is designed for bigger kids. “The bathrooms, the fountains and classrooms were built for kids almost at adult size,” said Libby. “It’s just not acceptable for our kids.”

Though Messer agrees there are problems with both schools, he said $55 million is just too much and he believes the schools could be fixed for about half the cost.

According to Mitchell, while some money could be saved with smaller classrooms or by building a smaller gym, building a school for half of the proposed amount is impossible.

“I’m not saying you can’t do it for $5 million less, but $25 million? I’m not sure what type of structure you’d have for $25 million less,” said Mitchell. “I suppose you could without a gym. To say you can cut $25 million, it’s almost not worth comment. You could eliminate the air conditioning, you could shrink the classrooms by 50 feet, but that doesn’t make any sense to me.”

Comments are no longer available on this story