It’s unfortunate that sporting goods outfitter Cabela’s has taken the position that without a favorable ruling on a sales tax exemption from the Maine Revenue Services, the company will not build a store in Maine.
If no one backs down in this fight, the company, Scarborough and the state would lose. The company will lose all the potential revenue from sales at a planned Scarborough store, Scarborough will lose a promising development for the Haigis Parkway, and the state will lose the jobs and tax revenue that could come from the store.
Cabela’s is seeking a private tax ruling from the state on whether the company can continue to exempt its Maine catalog customers from the state’s sales tax. Cabela’s argues that legally, it is actually three distinct companies – physical stores, Internet sales and catalog sales. Because its catalog and Internet companies would continue to be based outside the state, the company does not believe its catalog and Internet customers should be penalized because the company that runs the physical stores has decided to build a store here.
While this argument might be justifiable under a strict interpretation of the law, on its face, it doesn’t seem fair. The three companies that make up Cabela’s are obviously affiliated under the same name. The three companies obviously sell some of the same products manufactured in some of the same places. So, why should these companies get a tax break other businesses throughout Maine don’t get?
Theoretically, any business could divide its sales from catalogs and the Internet into a separate company. In reality, however, smaller businesses don’t have the resources to make such a distinction. And, doing so for most of them would simply be a way to avoid paying the tax.
Even larger companies, like L.L. Bean, ask customers to pay a sales tax in states where the company has stores. Despite that fact, L.L. Bean is being a little disingenuous in its opposition to this. As Sen. Lynn Bromley (D-South Portland) points out in a guest column that appears on this page, L.L. Bean is the recipient of an exclusive tax break of its own.
L.L. Bean gets an exemption from the business equipment tax for being a business that has more than 100,000 square feet of floor space and does more than 30 percent of its business with customers located outside of Maine – a break obviously tailor-made for L.L. Bean.
How does a business get such an exclusive exemption? The answer is easy. It makes enough money to buy some influence over public policy, which is exactly what Cabela’s is trying to do now.
If the Maine Revenue Services decides in favor of Cabela’s, then this might all be moot. However, if the Maine Revenue Services decides exempting catalog customers of Cabela’s is illegal or inequitable, the company – or companies – should accept the decision. It stands to gain much more from its sales at a new store in Maine than it stands to lose through catalog customers paying the state sales tax.
-Brendan Moran, editor
Comments are no longer available on this story