6 min read

A plan to build a town park off Black Point Road in Scarborough has upset neighbors who feel they weren’t informed of the town’s plans and planning board members who feel the plan should have gotten their approval before going forward with construction.

Construction work on Black Point Community Park, which will include lighted athletic fields, a basketball court, walking trails and playground equipment, began last week. Despite that, planning board members didn’t see the plans for the park until Monday night.

Many neighbors to the park, which will be bordered by Fogg Road, Black Point Road, Highland Avenue and Lancaster Lane, are concerned about the effect the park will have on parking and traffic. The neighbors concerned include the St. Maximilian Kolbe Parish Council and Father Michael Henchal. Many of the concerned neighbors were frustrated they couldn’t speak at the meeting because it was not a public hearing.

Scarborough Community Services is building the park. Community Services held a neighborhood meeting June 13, and Community Services Director Bruce Gullifer said he has already incorporated some of the concerns expressed at that meeting into the plan.

The planning board was asked to give its opinion on the park Monday night, but not their approval. According to Town Manager Ron Owens, since this is town owned property donated by KDA Construction, only the Town Council’s approval is needed for Community Services to go forward with construction.

“Frankly, this is a little embarrassing,” said board Chairman Susan Auglis. She questioned why the board was even involved at all since site preparation had already begun.

Advertisement

She also said that by not including the board’s approval the town is not being held to the same standards any other developer must adhere to.

“I think that’s a misguided comment,” Owens said in an interview. “It’s hard for a recreation area to be judged in the same way a developer would be.”

Concerns about park

Auglis and other board members are concerned that by not seeing detailed plans for lighting, entrances, environmental impact and traffic flow, the fields could cause problems for residents.

Auglis said her concerns don’t stem from a lack of trust for Community Services. “I think that we should just know in advance what’s happening,” she said.

Residents who attended the meeting were also left confused, both by the fact that the board’s approval is not required and that they weren’t able to voice their concerns.

Advertisement

In early June, residents that immediately border the park area were sent notices to attend an information session held by Gullifer. On June 13 at the neighborhood meeting, they heard about the plans and talked about their concerns of traffic, noise, lighting and safety.

Many, said John Plunkett, were under the impression they could speak at the Planning Board meeting. Since it wasn’t a public hearing, they were told Monday night they would have to wait.

According to both Owens and Gullifer, they will have a chance to share their opinions on the park construction, both at another neighborhood meeting and at a public hearing to be held by the Town Council.

“To say that people were disappointed and frustrated that this wasn’t the proper forum is an accurate statement,” said Plunkett, the chairman of the St. Maximilian Kolbe Parish Council.

Plunkett and Father Michael Henchal are concerned that St. Maximilian’s parking lot will become overflow parking areas for people attending sports events.

The church is one of the properties that directly borders the fields. Its parking lot is closest.

Advertisement

“It’s very important to us that this not be perceived as a not-in-our-backyard thing,” said Henchal. “We’re not opposed to creating a field if a field is needed. It’s just a question of making sure problems are addressed.”

Since Scarborough and Cape Elizabeth have consolidated their Catholic churches, Henchal is not only concerned that there isn’t enough parking for all parishioners, but that events on the field will only heighten the parking problem.

A need for fields

According to Gullifer, there is a need to build more athletic fields. “The town keeps growing and as it continues to grow we try to grow with it,” said Gullifer. “We certainly don’t have enough space as it is.”

The site preparation is as far as construction will go for now, said Gullifer. Each year Community Services hopes to do a little more, about $400,000 worth of work at a time. By completing construction in smaller phases that do not cost more than $400,000, they will not have to go to a referendum.

According to Owens, only site preparation will happen this year. The Town Council has not yet approved any of the layout for fields or further construction.

Advertisement

“This is just the start of the process,” he said.

But residents are still worried the fields will cause too many problems if passed as currently planned.

SuAnn Carriero of Lancaster Lane is worried that her four children will not be safe with increased traffic and no sidewalks on Fogg Road. For Carriero, the park is not the issue. She will bring her children there to play once it’s built, but worries that traffic hasn’t been addressed.

“In all honesty, when we went to that Planning Board meeting, it seemed like a done deal,” he said.

“I don’t think there’s much we can do about it,” said Lorraine LaChapelle. “Hopefully, they’ll use our input.”

According to Gullifer, community input is important. In response to the first neighborhood meeting, some parking spaces close to the LaChapelles’ yard were removed, playground equipment was added, and the entrance from Fogg Road was moved a few feet away from a driveway.

Advertisement

He also said Community Services would consider eliminating the lights.

“You’re not going to make everybody happy,” said Gullifer. “But we do want to make as many people happy as possible.”

For the next neighborhood meeting, Henchal hopes more people are told to come. For the first information session, only immediate abutters like St. Maximilian were sent notices.

“It has to be more than just immediate abutters,” said Henchal. “People who live across the street will certainly be impacted.”

Larissa Pratt lives on Elbridge Oliver Way in the Highlands development. Though they are not touching the park area, they are still close enough for lights, noise and traffic to reach them.

“I’m in favor of having it in place, but I’m upset that we weren’t told,” said Pratt.

Advertisement

After coaching her son’s T-ball team she thinks a field would be nice, but hopes that it is properly managed to allow access to all of Scarborough’s teams.

“It certainly will not be a free-for-all,” said Gullifer. He added that Community Services will carefully oversee who uses the fields and when. A potential way to find money for upkeep and construction would be to rent out the fields to other towns. According to Gullifer, that is just a thought and wouldn’t necessarily be the case.

No exact date has been set for the next neighborhood meeting, but Gullifer expects it to happen within the next month.

“We’re looking to get a general discussion,” said Owens. “We want to balance residents’ concerns with the town’s needs.”

The park entrance off of Black Point Road, in the first stages of construction, is between two residences and passes close to St. Maximilian Kolbe. The entrance from Black Point Road has residents worried about increased traffic. The LaChapelles’ home on Fogg Road is only a few feet away from the park. The LaChapelles can walk through their backyard to the park area only a few feet away.

Comments are no longer available on this story