3 min read

Cape Elizabeth’s school board is taking a stand against a statewide citizen initiative to limit spending because they believe it will disable their ability to continue providing quality education.

The board voted unanimously last week in favor of a resolution that opposes the Taxpayer Bill of Rights. The resolution cited the bill’s “unconstitutional” restraints on voting and the damage it would cause to the quality of education statewide as reasons to oppose it.

However, supporters of the initiative, which is also known as TABOR, argue that the bill would force largely administrative cuts that are needed to reduce the size of Maine government.

Rebecca Millett, finance chair of Cape’s school board, said the initiative can only hurt education in Cape. The schools, she said, have already felt the pains of a spending cap – one imposed by the Town Council two years ago.

“We can already see the effects. We’re very concerned about what a statewide cap would do,” said Millett.

Millett predicts that if the Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights is signed into law, Cape and other school systems statewide will see cuts in spending that will undermine their ability to provide a quality education. She predicts that classroom sizes will increase and programs will shrink, or worst yet, disappear altogether.

Advertisement

Scarborough resident and Taxpayer Bill of Rights campaigner Roy Lenardson disagrees. He said the only thing that will be shrinking is the belly of the gluttonous bureaucracy Maine taxpayers continually overfeed. Lenardson said Maine government duplicates where it should be consolidating services, which is at the crux of the tax problem.

Rather than having eight superintendents in Washington County, where there are about 4,500 students, why not consolidate administrative costs by having only one superintendent, he asked. With the current system, Lenardson said the only people gaining are the administrators. Lenardson knows there is another way.

“They can’t deliver services differently? No. They don’t want to,” said Lenardson.

Under tabor, spending increases would be determined by the rate of inflation, paired with any adjustment for population increases or decreases. According to Millett, the inflation rate is not an accurate reflection of education costs in Cape Elizabeth.

“There’s no flexibility for things like a 50 percent increase in energy,” she said.

Lenardson said even under the worst conditions, municipalities would not face decreases in spending. He predicts that on average, municipalities would have to learn to function within a 3 to 5 percent increase in spending annually.

Advertisement

Any spending above the cap must be approved by a two-thirds vote of any municipal government. Only then will it be passed onto voters. “Instead of an unlimited credit card, you get a debit card and the taxpayer decides how much to spend,” said Lenardson.

Millett said it could be difficult to get a resolution through to the voters at all with a required two-thirds majority vote from the council. “It allows a minority to rule,” she said.

For Millett, rejecting the Taxpayers Bill of Rights is a no-brainer. Voters choose leaders who they believe will spend their money wisely, said Millett. Elected officials don’t need an “artificial mechanism” to restrain spending, she said. Millett doubts that tabor’s true intent is restraining spending.

“I’m not sure TABOR is about taxpayer relief, but an effort to crush government,” she said.

Lenardson said the Taxpayers Bill of Rights is not only about restricting spending but about growing Maine’s economy. For Lenardson, Tabor is the “economic engine,” which will drive Maine back into the black. He is well aware that municipalities will fight against it, because ultimately it will decrease the size of government, but he said, “we’re going to fight back and we’re going to fight hard, because TABOR is what Maine needs.”

Comments are no longer available on this story