4 min read

State Police have asked for DNA samples from environmental protestors, including some members of the group Earth First, who say they had nothing to do with vandalism last October that targeted people working on the controversial Plum Creek development around Moosehead Lake.

While State Police are declining to say the Plum Creek attacks were their motivation for the DNA requests, Will Neils, a member of Earth First in Maine, said the one thing in common among all who have been asked is their vocal opposition to Plum Creek.

“They’re just focusing on people who are speaking their minds,” Neils said, adding they’re not all Earth First members.

“It’s not exclusive to Earth First. It’s actually exclusive to Plum Creek,” he said.

Stephen McCausland, spokesman for the state Department of Public Safety, said the State Police went after the DNA “in connection with ongoing investigations,” which he would not discuss. Asked specifically if it was about Plum Creek, he said he would not say.

“We have the right to ask anyone for DNA,” McCausland said. “They also have the right to refuse. Most did.”

Advertisement

The dozen or so people being asked for their DNA were, in part, connected to a group that tried to camp out illegally on Sears Island in April. Earth First organized the event to bring people together for environmental education and organization training and to protest development of the island. Sears Island belongs to the state and is under the jurisdiction of the Maine Department of Transportation. There has been talk in the past of building a liquefied natural gas facility on it.

Neils was one of a handful of campers who had their camping gear confiscated by police, but later returned. He said when he went to pick it up on April 29, police asked him for a DNA sample – usually taken with a mouth swab – and fingerprints.

Neils declined, telling police they already had his fingerprints from an arrest in 2000 when he and some others locked themselves in an office at the Department of Labor to protest policies displacing Maine loggers in the North Woods.

About a month later, State Police went knocking on doors of others who attended the event.

Earth First made its name in the 1980s in the Pacific Northwest, with members chaining themselves to logging equipment, sitting in trees and sometimes putting metal spikes in trees, making them dangerous to cut.

But Neils said his group had nothing to do with vandalism last October, where three homes and three office buildings were splattered with paint, animal feces and foul-smelling chemicals.

Advertisement

Those included the offices of attorney Severin Beliveau and what vandals apparently thought was his home in Hallowell, which was nearby to the house attacked.

Beliveau, a powerful figure in Augusta who led Gov. John Baldacci’s transition commission when he was first elected, is now representing Plum Creek.

“Absolutely not,” Neils said, when asked if his group was involved in that vandalism spree.

“Plum Creek has infuriated thousands of people who live in this state with their level of contempt for what Mainers want,” Neils said. “They’ve pissed off so many people, it’s impossible to know who went after them.”

Plum Creek wants to build 975 homes and two resorts in the Moosehead Lake region on land they purchased from the Sappi paper company in 1998. They presented one plan last year, which was withdrawn under heavy public criticism, and a revised one was submitted on April 27 – the same day police started investigating the Sears Island campers.

While Neils claims Beliveau is pressuring the governor to come down hard on protestors, the vandalism spree was condemned across-the-board last year, even by those groups stridently opposed to Plum Creek’s plans.

Advertisement

Some of those same groups, however, said last week that asking people, who have not been charged in a case, to submit DNA to the State Police is over the top.

Judy Berk, a spokeswoman for the Natural Resources Council of Maine, said asking the people who attempted to camp on Sears Island to give DNA samples was a form of intimidation and a kind of a “witch-hunt.”

“Nobody was arrested or charged. That’s what’s so troubling about this incident. There was no incident. And here they are approaching people in their home and asking them for DNA samples, which is about the most personal information you can give,” Berk said.

She said it “reflected badly on the State Police.”

“I don’t know what the State Police are investigating,” Berk said, but the DNA request “potentially will have a chilling effect on free speech.”

Baldacci’s spokeswoman, Crystal Canney, said the governor wasn’t getting involved in the investigation.

“The governor wouldn’t want to inhibit them from collecting consensual evidence in an investigation,” she said. “We don’t get in the middle of State Police and how they do their investigations.”

State Rep. Janet Mills, D-Farmington, who was a district attorney for 15 years in a district that included parts of Franklin, Oxford and Androscoggin counties, said she wasn’t taking a position on the State Police’s case, but thinks voluntarily giving up one’s DNA is a bad idea.

“I would never advise anybody to voluntarily give DNA samples to police because you don’t know what kind of database it’s going into or what it will be used for,” she said. “There are shades of J. Edgar Hoover in this episode.”

Comments are no longer available on this story