4 min read

Scarborough residents questioned whether the town’s new comprehensive plan does enough to create affordable housing at a public hearing Tuesday night.

“I’m disappointed. I thought it would have more teeth,” said Suzanne Foley-Ferguson, a member of the Scarborough Housing Alliance.

The Comprehensive Plan Update Committee held the hearing Tuesday before voting next week on whether to send the plan to the Planning Board and Town Council. The committee will vote on any final revisions to the plan at a meeting at 6:30 p.m. Tuesday, May 30.

The update fulfills Maine law and helps Scarborough grow efficiently and wisely without destroying the environment and the character of neighborhoods and villages. It will help appropriately balance residential and business areas as well as designate where those areas should be.

It will also include a growth cap to ensure that the fast growing population doesn’t outpace the town’s ability to provide services. Since the last Comprehensive Plan update the population has increased by about 5,000, according to Assistant Town Planner Dan Bacon.

The plan also includes ways to improve housing diversity by encouraging developers to build more affordable housing. One of the plan’s recommendations is to give developers interested in building in Scarborough a 10 percent density bonus for projects that offer affordable housing. The bonus is only available if 33 to 40 percent of the units qualify as affordable housing.

Advertisement

The plan would also allow certain areas to have multi-family buildings, apartments over businesses, senior housing, condominiums and other smaller homes that are typically more affordable. Overall, the plan now reccomends that 10 percent of all homes built in the next 10 years should be affordable housing.

Sylvia Most, one of the chairs of the Update Committee, emphasized the importance of including provisions for more affordable housing. “Over the next 10-year period housing affordability is going to be an issue,” said Most.

Although he called the updated plan “terrific,” resident Jack Cowie said he is concerned it still doesn’t fully address affordable housing. “Imagine a young family in their late 20s, possibly with one or two kids trying to buy their first house,” said Cowie. “It isn’t happening any more in Scarborough.”

Cowie’s main concern is that while the plan recommends that 25 percent of all future development is non-residential, the people who will work for these new businesses might not be able to purchase homes in the town they work for. Though he said not everyone who works in Scarborough has to live here, he believes they should have that opportunity.

“We want to be friends and neighbors with the people who can’t afford to live here,” said Cowie.

Like Cowie, Foley-Ferguson also began by saying she believes the plan is generally well prepared. However, she still sees room for improvement.

Advertisement

Foley-Ferguson suggested that the Update Committee use the affordable housing study the Housing Alliance recently completed. According to Foley-Ferguson, the Alliance’s study is more up to date and therefore more accurate.

“The barriers for affordable housing you say need to be identified have been identified,” said Foley-Ferguson. “We identified them.”

According to Most, at this point deleting an entire section and adding in a new one would not be feasible. The committee is also concerned that using a study submitted from the Housing Alliance could be construed as a form of advocacy. As a compromise, the plan will refer to the Alliance’s study.

Rick Shinay, the other chair of the committee, said the committee would be looking at ways to tweak the language in the portion of the plan devoted to affordable housing. “It seems we’ve done as much (as possible) in the plan to encourage affordable housing without mandating it,” said Shinay.

“The goal is good,” said Shinay. “Whether it can be achieved, who knows. I support the objective.”

Another piece of the plan the committee is considering revising is the allowed sizes of buildings in the Dunstan area. Dunstan and Oak Hill are identified in the plan as community centers where non-residential growth can occur. Currently the plan would allow for businesses, such as restaurants, hotels, office buildings and other small-scale retail stores.

Joe Malone, who was representing Scarborough landowner Bob Harrisburg, asked the Committee to consider allowing larger buildings in the 100 acres Harrisburg owns around Dunstan. According to Malone, businesses like grocery stores while large can create vital town centers that are easily accessible and pedestrian friendly.

After next Tuesday’s Comprehensive Plan Committee’s meeting, the plan will be reviewed by both the Town Council and the Planning Board. Once it is passed by both groups, the final approval will come from the state. These final reviews should happen within the next few months.

Comments are no longer available on this story