The Scarborough Town Council has approved the school budget at $300,000 less than requested by the Board of Education.
The council’s decision eliminates money that the school department was hoping to use to add new teaching positions and upgrade some existing positions.
The Board of Education’s decision to both add new teachers and upgrade some positions to full-time came late in the budgeting process. Superintendent William Michaud and the board estimated that healthcare costs would increase this year by 15 percent. According to Michaud, healthcare increases have been “approaching double digits for a long time.”
Just days before the board reviewed the budget, the school’s healthcare provider, Blue Cross/Blue Shield, released an increase of just five percent. This left about $200,000 no longer needed for healthcare. Instead of lowering the budget by that amount, members of the board wanted to use that money to add or upgrade some teaching positions.
The vote to send a proposed budget with the $200,000 to the Town Council was 4-3 in favor. Voting against the budget were board members Robert Mitchell, Dianne Messer and Chris Brownsey.
At the time, Brownsey said he was “not a supporter of adding those positions,” though he added the positions would have been helpful to the school. He voted against allocating the extra money because he believes the board’s policy is to remove any money that was overestimated.
Brownsey also said that he is disappointed the council “cut the budget by $300,000 rather than something less.”
Mitchell voted against adding all five positions, though he felt some were appropriate.
“I thought that the right move would be to add in two, possibly three positions,” said Mitchell. “It didn’t seem to be right to add back in all the positions. Now, unfortunately, we have a $300,000 adjustment to deal with rather than $200,000.”
Even though healthcare needs were $200,000 less than anticipated, the Council reduced the budget by $300,000, to $27.1 million instead of the Board’s proposed $27.4 million.
Town Council member Jeff Messer is in favor of the $27.1 million budget. “Quite frankly, my belief was to get the tax rate down to about one percent,” he said.
Messer said he saw an opportunity to help reduce taxes for Scarborough by taking out unnecessary money.
According to Messer, if the Council had “really wanted to cut to the bone, we could have cut about $600,000.” Messer added that they did not do so due to the upcoming vote on the Taxpayer Bill of Rights.
In November, Maine will vote on the Taxpayer Bill of Rights, and if passed it will impose a spending cap on all levels of government, making it difficult to increase taxes and fees.
Messer believes the measure will succeed, and will make it much harder on the board’s budgets in coming years. By not cutting as much as he believed possible, Messer said it would ultimately help the schools.
Michaud does not agree.
According to Michaud, the board would have readjusted the budget had the healthcare increases not been released at “the 11th hour.” Because it happened so close to the review of the budget, he felt that it was a good opportunity to add positions they had already found necessary.
The jobs in the board’s proposed budget were two upgrades of part time teachers to fulltime, one high school teacher, one resource room teacher at Wentworth Intermediate and one kindergarten teacher.
“The positions would have made a big difference,” said Michaud. “They are basically things that would have helped students academically.”
Michaud sites growing classroom sizes as a reason for the new teachers. The highest average is 21 per class at Wentworth, with the middle school right behind with about 20. The high school and Pleasant Hill school are the lowest at around 18. For the entire district the average class size comes out to 19.
According to Michaud, for some types of classes these are not high numbers, but for others, they are far from optimal. For something like an advanced placement lab science class, he sees 19 students as much too high.
Michaud said that even though the budget is less than recommended, the schools would still try to add a kindergarten teacher “because the numbers demand it.”
Michaud said the size for some kindergarten classes is 24, and a new teacher will reduce that to 17. Though 17 students per class is the school’s goal, according to Michaud, some board members feel that even 15 students is not low enough.
Messer does not believe that enrollment numbers support the Board’s decision to add the teachers. For 2006, there were a total of 3,314 students in the district. In 2007, enrollment is expected to increase by 39 students. The high school will likely see the biggest increase, at 32 students. According to Messer, this is a relatively low increase.
Messer also said that with the high school project just finishing and with the upcoming vote on rebuilding two more schools, reducing the budget was the right thing to do in order to help Scarborough taxpayers.
Though Michaud would have liked the budget to stay at the proposed $27.4 million complete with five new positions, he “can see both sides of it. The Town Council is just trying to pass savings on to the taxpayers.”
Comments are no longer available on this story