Last week, a Cumberland County Superior Court judge denied Peter and Carolyn Biegel’s appeal that would have prevented Pit Stop Fuels from being built near Colonial Marketplace on Route 25.
The lawsuit, filed last June against the town of Standish, Pit Stop Fuels, Inc. and its owner, Dana Lampron, questioned the legality of the Planning Board’s approval of Pit Stop’s site plan application, claiming it was not a retail business but a warehouse operation, which is a prohibited use in the Village Center District.
In his decision, Judge Robert Crowley stated, “Although the record strongly indicates that the ZBA (Zoning Board of Appeals) did not consider whether the underground fuel oil storage tanks should be allowed as part of the special use exception…the ZBA’s approval was predicated upon its finding that the plans presented to it in fact constituted a ‘retail use.’ Moreover, the Planning Board had no authority of its own to make findings on the nature of the use.”
But Crowley also said in his ruling that it appeared the ZBA didn’t question whether the plans that were presented to them in the category of retail business should be categorized as retail business.
Attorney Tim Norton, who represents the Biegels, said he was surprised by the ruling and added that “the court sort of agreed with us.”
“What it says is the Biegels needed to appeal the Zoning Board decision,” Norton said. “I think that the judge basically said, ‘look, I agree with you,’ but whether or not the ZBA realized what they were doing is unclear.”
In a recent phone interview, Carolyn Biegel said she is “appalled” by the decision and by the town’s attitude.
“It goes to show that if you try to mislead a board and you’re successful then that’s okay,” she said. “The lesson I’m learning is it’s okay to lie to your citizens; it’s okay to misrepresent the truth.”
She also referred to the buffer zone the Planning Board had required of Lampron. Though it was not a part of the lawsuit, the Planning Board, as part of their approval for the project, had instructed Lampron not to cut down existing trees. But in February, the entire buffer between Pit Stop and Route 25 was cleared.
“They all say it (the Pit Stop) fit the character because of the trees that are there, but he mowed them down,” Biegel said. “How does this benefit Standish?”
As a result of the clearing, Lampron was cited, but not fined, by both the town and the Department of Environmental Protection and ordered to submit a thorough landscaping plan with approved amounts, varieties and sizes of vegetation.
When questioned about the buffer strip, Lampron said once the danger of frost is past he will complete the planting.
Responding to the outcome of the lawsuit, Lampron, who hopes to have his Pit Stop operating by early July, said he was pleased by the judge’s ruling.
“I was happy,” he said. “I thought it was a silly request.”
According to Norton, the Biegel’s attorney, he and the Biegels will be studying the judge’s decision and will determine whether to appeal within the next week.
The completed shell of the Pit Stop Fuels building on Route 25 stands near the Manley Smith house, which will be moved from the property. Owner Dana Lampron expects his gasoline station, convenience store and fuel oil business to be completed sometime in July.
Comments are no longer available on this story