4 min read

Cape Elizabeth elected officials wrangled over how much money the schools needed to support and maintain the historically “excellent” school system at last week’s joint Town Council and School Board meeting.

Some town councilors staunchly supported sticking by a spending cap pledged in 2004, while others favored spending above the council imposed limit.

Cape elected officials avoided setting a definitive number for school spending until they hear more from the public on April 26. The council will hold a public hearing on the town and school budgets April 26 at 7:30 p.m. at Town Hall.

The school board officially presented their final budget and asked for a 7 percent increase in spending, which the council overwhelmingly agreed would not be approved. However, a slight majority of councilors favored spending somewhere between 3.4 percent and 7 percent. Paired with the town budget, which abides by the cap, increasing overall spending by 3.4 percent, the tax increase stands at somewhere between 16 and 62 cents of every $1,000 of property value.

The major point of contention throughout the evening was the topic of increasing enrollment. Some councilors felt strongly that the school board should be compensated for past years when enrollment increased but funding failed to reflect that increase, while others said they would not vote to increase spending above the cap when enrollment was projected to decrease.

Councilors argued for and against increases for enrollment based on population projections that School Board Finance Chair Rebecca Millett called “highly suspect.”

Advertisement

Councilors Cynthia Dill, David Backer, Paul McKenney and Mike Mowles agreed that there should be added money for enrollment increases. Anne-Swift Kayatta, Mary Ann Lynch and Carol Fritz said they’d make no exceptions for enrollment increases.

For the past five years, the enrollment calculator the town is using has under-predicted student enrollment by 46 students on average yearly. For this school year, the actual enrollment was 63 students higher than first predicted in 2003. Since 2004, enrollment has increased by 38 students, 18 of those students require special education, which costs more. School systems partly base their annual budget on cost per student. In Cape, education costs about $9,090 per student.

Lynch argued that because enrollment was projected to decrease by 30 from 1,847 to 1,817 students, she could not support adding positions. Millett said she doesn’t know when enrollment will level off. “Obviously, if you plot the line, it keeps going up,” she said.

The school board’s 7 percent budget would have added part-time positions that totaled three and a half full-time positions. A school nurse and a counselor for Pond Cove were among the added positions. Millett said after factoring position reductions, only one full-time position was added.

In the past two months, teachers and parents have rallied in opposition to the cap, urging the school board to reject it. Answering the call of their supporters, the board rejected the cap when they approved an amended version of the superintendent’s first budget. The first budget obeyed the 3.4 percent spending cap and would have eliminated several positions, laptop funding and furniture replacement.

However, not everybody supports spending above the cap for the schools. Some residents at the meeting appealed to councilors not to spend above the cap. They argued that they couldn’t afford their rising property taxes.

Advertisement

“I’m an old person who lives in an old house,” said Cape resident Charles McCarthy. “There are not all rich people in this town…I’m having difficulty staying in the house I’ve been in for 38 years.”

Retiree Robert Shuman said he’s being taxed out of his home. Shuman suggested creating a system to avoid overburdening the elderly and those on fixed incomes. He recommended freezing taxes at age 65 or freezing taxes at a percentage of income.

As for town and school spending, he said, “we’d be better to live within the cap, even if it’s a little uncomfortable.”

Council Chairman David Backer read e-mails from residents opposed to spending above the cap. The schools have been heard, he said, but there is a group that hasn’t been heard. “They’re not well organized, don’t have an e-mail distribution or a Web site,” he said.

This group of people is akin to McCarthy and Shuman. They’re not wealthy, they live on a budget and they can’t afford substantial increases in their tax rate. “Everyone is up in arms that teachers aren’t getting decent raises. Well, neither am I,” wrote one resident. “I live on a budget and don’t spend more than I make.”

Backer said he wanted to remind people that this particular viewpoint exists. However, Backer said he would support an increase over the cap for a population increase over the years.

Advertisement

Millett said she is grateful a majority of the council has kept an open mind about the cap. “It’s encouraging that four councilors recognize that the cap isn’t sufficient,” said Millett.

School Board member Trish Brigham said that though she doubted the council would approve a 7 percent budget, a 5.5 percent budget, which was at one point proposed by Councilor Cynthia Dill, is insufficient.

An increase of “5.5 is certainly more acceptable, but does it meet the defined needs? No,” said Brigham. Brigham suggested increasing revenue rather than cutting costs.

“Expenditures are as tight as they can be,” she said. Brigham suggested Fort Williams as a possible stream of revenue for the town and schools.

The council will vote on the final budget May 15 during its regularly scheduled monthly meeting.

Comments are no longer available on this story