I am writing to express my disappointment with the preliminary approval given by the Cape Elizabeth Planning Board to the proposed Spurwink Woods subdivision. There are many reasons why I am opposed to this subdivision as it is currently proposed, too many to include in one letter, so I will address the issue of cluster housing.
The Planning Board would have us believe that the cluster housing plan for Spurwink Woods is in the best interest of Cape Elizabeth. The rationale behind cluster housing is that the increased density protects the natural environment by preserving more open space. In the case of Spurwink Woods, however, approximately 15 acres of old growth pine forest habitat will be destroyed, a habitat that could be saved in a more thoughtful conventional plan. The town planner argues that there would be less open space in a conventional plan. The 10.48 acres of proposed open space in Spurwink Woods consists of a scrubby knoll of bedrock and RP-1 and 2 wetlands, an undevelopable area due to wetland constraints that would continue to be open space in any plan.
Conventional development does not preclude open space and walking trails, as evidenced in Cross Hill. A between-lot, no-cut tree buffer of any size can easily be established in a subdivision covenant, thus preserving as much of the natural habitat as desired. The Planning Board only has to make these things a condition of development.
Spurwink Woods has been cited as the fifth largest proposed housing development in the state of Maine. This is a dubious distinction for a town whose residents view the preservation of its natural landscape as the highest priority (Cape Elizabeth Comprehensive Plan Survey, November 2006). Cluster housing should be implemented only when it benefits the natural environment, not when it is to its detriment. It is not too late for the Planning Board to reconsider the direction of Spurwink Woods.
Claudia Dricot
Cape Elizabeth
Comments are no longer available on this story