The Cape police may soon be looking for a new person to lead their union in its contract dispute with the town.
Union president Mark Dorval recently submitted resumes to several other police departments, both in Maine and Connecticut. His decision to leave the Cape police after five years of service was partly due to the strain of an eight-month contract negotiation that stalemated over retirement benefits, he said.
The union represents eight police officers, three sergeants and four dispatchers.
Dorval has spearheaded the union’s fight to return to the state retirement system. Contract negotiations have been underway since June 2005.
The union is asking that the town buy back into the Maine State Retirement System with a 25 year/no age and 50 percent pay package. Their current benefit package is a contribution plan with the town investing 7 percent of an employee’s salary. The town has offered to increase their contribution to 10 percent over 3 years.
Dorval said he assumes the other union members will pick up where he will leave off. “I tell everybody to toe the line, don’t give into the council,” he said.
Though Dorval has two small sons and recently built a house, he is willing to uproot his family for advancement opportunities and a better retirement package. He said he is scheduled in early March for a written test in Windsor Conn., and a physical agility test with a Maine department. He declined to reveal the name of the Maine department.
Although a better retirement package isn’t his only reason for looking outside of Cape, Dorval said it is a dominant factor. “When you don’t get the respect you deserve from the town, you start looking at other places,” said Dorval, “If I’m going to make a move, I might as well do it now,” he said.
Dorval and others in the department claim that retirement benefits are a major employee retention tool. They have said they believe insufficient benefits could lead to a transient department.
“If they want a training ground, that’s the direction they’re heading. If they want a department that’s professional and loyal, they need to take a different course,” said Dorval.
Town Council Chairman David Backer said employee retention is always a high priority. “Ideally we would like to see officers come to Cape as long term employees.”
However, Backer said a small department like Cape’s doesn’t offer much for advancement or excitement. “If some young cop wants glitz and glamour in law enforcement, they won’t find that in Cape,” he said.
He said it is the nature of a small town department that lends itself to a transient workforce. “It’s possible that a small town department will always be a training ground, regardless of retirement,” he said.
Detective Paul Fenton, also a member of the negotiating team, said there is no doubt that small departments face challenges in keeping officers, but it should be the town’s priority to devise creative retention strategies.
Fenton posed the question to the council, “what have you done to try and fix it?”
Dorval, said Fenton, is one of the top officers in the department and the town should do what is in their power to retain him. “They should be saying, ‘what will make you stay?,'” said Fenton.
Dorval is the community liaison officer in the station. In his position, he works with the school systems, as a member of the high school substance abuse subcommittee and coordinates the senior citizen Triad group.
Police Chief Neil Williams said Dorval “is doing a great job” and is a “great employee.” He said it would be unfortunate to lose Dorval.
Williams said he’s warned his employees of the hardship of contract negotiations. “I have to explain that this could be a long road and we have to work through it,” said Williams.
The union maintains that retirement benefits are a sticking point to retention. Williams said last August, during hiring, one highly rated candidate declined the position because the town did not offer a state retirement package.
Cape Elizabeth Police Union president Mark Dorval is seeking other employment, partly due to what he considers an insufficient retirement package with the Cape Police Department.
Comments are no longer available on this story