A judge has ruled that the town of Scarborough is not responsible for the more than $40,000 in legal fees incurred by John and Elliott Chamberlain for a portion of their suit against the town.
The Chamberlains sued the town last year after a contract zone that would have allowed the construction of 397-units at Dunstan was overturned by a resident initiated referendum.
The primary argument in the Chamberlains’ suit is that the town’s comprehensive plan was inconsistent with its zoning ordinances. In February, Cumberland County Superior Court Judge Thomas Warren ruled in their favor on this point and ordered the town to change the zoning.
Elliott Chamberlain did not return several calls seeking comment.
In July, the Town Council approved a new zoning ordinance that allowed for the construction of up to 288 units. The Chamberlains are now using this zoning ordinance for their project and late last year amended their plan to include 264 units.
The Chamberlains felt the town should cover their $41,319 in legal fees because, they argued, the town knew it had little chance of winning the suit. They felt the town denied the fact that the comprehensive plan was inconsistent with the zoning ordinances even though it knew that was not true, costing them money.
In court documents, they point to several news stories written on the issue where town officials admitted the town had little chance of winning as evidence.
“Plaintiffs should not have to bear the financial burden of the town’s decision to deny a fact it knew to be true,” a court document reads.
Judge Warren did not believe the town felt that there was no chance of winning and in court documents said the town had “established – albeit just barley – that its arguments were respectable enough that it has a reasonable grounds to believe that it might prevail.”
The issue seems to be the last one relating to the suit since the Chamberlains have begun the planning process for the Dunstan development.
Town Manager Ron Owens said he hopes the suit will now be dropped. In previous “informal” discussions with the Chamberlains, Owens said they have indicated the suit would be dropped, but added that there is a chance the decision will be appealed.
“My expectation is that this will mean the end of the lawsuit and they will drop the remaining charges,” he said.
Comments are no longer available on this story