Local school administrators believe consolidating Maine’s school districts, from 286 to 35, would be a tough sell.
School regionalization was just one of several controversial recommendations outlined in a report commissioned by the Maine State Board of Education. It was authored by a select committee, which included former Gov. Angus King, former University of Maine Chancellor Robert Woodbury and Commissioner of Education Susan Gendron.
“It’s a kind of over the edge,” said Cape Elizabeth Superintendent Alan Hawkins.
Regionalization is a touchy subject, he said, because Maine’s culture promotes strong local government. “Keeping local control and streamlining just don’t match up,” he said.
Wendy Houlihan, South Portland superintendent, recounted a 2001 referendum in which residents voted in favor of maintaining smaller elementary schools. “That sense of local control is embedded deeply in Maine,” she said.
Hawkins anticipates a difficult debate on the horizon. “People feel very strongly about their school system. They’re not going to jump for joy,” at consolidating with other districts, he said.
The report cites statistics that Maine’s schools are the eighth most expensive in the nation. Maine’s administrator-per-student ratio is alarmingly high compared to the national average. In 2001-2002, Maine had one administrator for every 393, whereas the national average was one for every 816.
By paring down administration and aligning it closer with national averages, the state could save upwards of $270 million a year, according to the report, though the report also concedes this is unlikely because of the rural nature of the state.
Scarborough Superintendent Bill Michaud said he is unclear where the savings would come from. “Maybe it’s there, but I don’t see it,” he said. Michaud does not think the recommended 35 school districts aligned with the senate districts could adequately manage the school system.
“The idea is seductive, but I’m not sure it’s realistic,” said Michaud.
He felt that this was particularly true for the more urban part of the state where school districts like his own already have 2,500 to 3,500 students.
Michaud also pointed to the difficulty in implementing some of the recommendations, including the state bargaining unit intended to level teacher pay. He said the divided nature of the state would pose problems achieving this goal.
He wonders if it’s feasible to mandate a standard pay across the state. “The cost of living is so varied that I don’t think what teachers make in York county is going to be realistic for Aroostook County,” he said.
Maine is ranked 47th in the nation in starting teacher salaries. According to a survey conducted by Maine School Management, the average starting salary was $26,910. This figure was based on 119 school districts who answered the survey. Approximately 54 percent of school districts participated. Scarborough starts their teachers at $28,282, and Cape Elizabeth pays $30,047 to first year teachers.
Assuming $30,000 as a benchmark starting salary, Michaud wondered how the state would close that $3,000 gap. “A $30,000 base state-wide is going to take some serious fundraising on somebody’s part,” he said.
Hawkins said that he thought the report was a good spring-board for discussion about the structure of Maine’s school system. If such drastic changes as suggested in the report were implemented, he said it would take not only change on a system but a cultural level as well.
Comments are no longer available on this story