I’m curious why you elected to report this story (“Murder still haunts family, Jehovahs,” Aug. 31) in the manner you did.
I am not a Jehovah’s Witness, I am a former member of the group who left because I believe they are wrong in their claim of having “the truth.” I am no apologist for them. However, this article as written is fairly offensive due to the fact that it represents an incredibly isolated event and almost seems to treat it as if it’s typical for Jehovah’s Witnesses. I’ve never heard of anything like this ever happening, but any group that is large enough is going to occasionally have a “member” who does something bad, and to present the actions of that individual as if they reflect on the group is extremely unfair.
The Witnesses have always been known as a pacifist organization. The fact that one of the members of the group committed a crime that was expressly against all their teachings and tenets, a crime that would disqualify him from even being considered one of Jehovah’s Witnesses, is shocking and extremely rare. Would it be considered fair to report on a community that rejected Catholics or Jews or black people on the basis of the acts of one mentally unbalanced individual over half a century earlier without at least making mention of the fact that the group itself stands for non-violence?
How is it any more relevant that this man was a Jehovah’s Witness than it is relevant that most murderers in this country likely declare different Christian denominations for themselves? How is it more relevant than somebody’s skin color or ethnicity?
This is a fairly biased presentation given in this article, and it seems to reflect a personal bias against the Witnesses. I have a personal bias against the group myself, but at least I know what they are about and don’t conflate the actions of an individual to a representation of the group.
Ryan Sutter
Burnsville, Minn.
Comments are no longer available on this story