WASHINGTON — In a new challenge to President Obama’s health care law, the Supreme Court appeared deeply and evenly divided Wednesday over the arrangement devised by the administration to spare faith-based groups from having to pay for birth control for women covered under their plans.
Ninety minutes of crisp arguments and frequent interruptions by the justices indicated that the court seemed headed for a 4-4 tie that would leave the issue unresolved nationally. Or the court could hold a new round of arguments once a ninth justice is confirmed to take the place of Justice Antonin Scalia, who died last month.
The case could factor into the fight over Obama’s Supreme Court nomination of Judge Merrick Garland. And in its volatile mix of religious liberty and birth control, it also could play a role in the presidential campaign. If the justices are as firmly split between liberals and conservatives as they signaled Wednesday, the court could say so as early as next week, or not until June.
Wednesday was the sixth anniversary of President Obama’s health care overhaul.The case in front of the justices is the law’s fourth Supreme Court appearance in five years.
Nationwide, eight appeals courts, including four with decisions being challenged in the current case, have sided with the administration, and one has ruled for the groups.
Chief Justice John Roberts, who has twice written opinions upholding the law against broad challenges, and Justice Samuel Alito repeatedly challenged Solicitor General Donald Verrilli Jr. on his argument that the policy strikes a balance between religious freedom and access to birth control.
Justice Anthony Kennedy, whose vote could give the administration a majority, also sounded sympathetic to the faith-based groups when he said that “religious organization plans here are, in effect, subsidizing the conduct that they deemed immoral.”
Justice Clarence Thomas asked no questions, but he has repeatedly sided with the challengers.
The four liberal justices seemed just as firmly in the administration’s corner. Justice Sonia Sotomayor said the administration’s arrangement takes into account women who are covered by the affected plans and “have a real need for contraceptives.” Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer and Elena Kagan also asked questions that signaled support.
“Sometimes when a religious person who’s not a hermit or a monk is a member of society, he does have to accept all kinds of things that are just terrible for him,” Breyer said.
Comments are no longer available on this story