Death Cab for Cutie was one of the earliest and biggest bands to break out to mainstream audiences thanks primarily to file-sharing.
Teenagers in dormitories and on their parents’ Internet connections discovered the band on Napster and Limewire (perhaps in part because of their eye-grabbing name) and shared the MP3s with their friends, giving the band exposure that eventually helped them net older generations as well.
By the time their 2003 album, “Transatlanticism,” made a big splash, it seemed like the arrival of the first rock band democratically elected by the Millennial generation.
The fact that a flagship young band of the dial-up-Internet heyday are now elder statesmen of new-millennium indie rock is a sure sign that we’re all getting older. But the band’s performance at the State Theatre in Portland, which was rescheduled when illness postponed their original engagement this spring, wasn’t part of a reunion or nostalgia-driven tour – they’ve put out an album every few years since the 1990s, and are currently promoting Kintsugi, a record released in March of this year.
As with many bands that have been around for so long, the classic material got bigger applause but the material from the latest album was stronger and more vital than the chestnuts, even if the album itself is a bit overwrought for my taste.
Their ode to Los Angeles, “El Dorado,” was one song I had overlooked that blossomed in a live setting. “You’ve Haunted Me All My Life” found Ben Gibbard taking a solo turn with an acoustic guitar; judging by the amount of smartphones in the air, it was a highlight for many.
The performance also brought out new perspectives on their older material. Gibbard’s voice, high and thin a decade ago, was once effortlessly capable of conveying youthful wonder and heartache, which was no doubt part of the band’s early appeal. As he’s grown older, his timbre has settled into deeper and raspier textures. It now sounds more world-weary, giving his older material new character.
A song such as “The New Year,” with the lyric “so this is the new year / and I don’t feel any different,” sounds more urgent and exhaustive now that there’s been roughly 12 New Years Eves since it was first performed.
With the recent departure of guitarist and co-songwriter Chris Walla, the band is more of a Gibbard vehicle than ever. He proved to be a lively front man, exuding more energy than I was expecting from a singer who can be somewhat deadpan on record.
The backing band was sturdy and frequently propulsive, although I missed the airy nature of the band’s earlier compositions – perhaps that was among Walla’s biggest contributions. Even when they reached back to their early 2000s material, as with an encore full of fan favorites, the songs seemed beefier than I recalled. Judging from the crowd response, I was the only one who minded.
Comments are no longer available on this story