4 min read

STANDISH — In the spirit of our present testing frenzy, here is a little quiz:

Question 1: What does “E Pluribus Unum” mean, and how does it tie into the debate about public education?

If you answered “Out of many, one,” you’re halfway there. Now, what does our national motto have to do with education? Sadly, it means we’ve got it in reverse. “Out of one, many” seems more the reality in education today. Have you seen any civics books recently? The citizenship test for our newest Americans?

Question 2: What do nearly all the nations which lead the U.S. educationally have in common? Answer: They directly and concertedly teach their country’s history and heritage.

Bottom line: We need to know who we were and who we are as a people before we have any chance of catching up with our competitors (who also have lower infant mortality rates and longer life spans).

The lesson these global achievers (Finland, Japan, Singapore, etc.) stunningly impart to us is our present need to figure out who we are before others figure it out for us.

Advertisement

This is a bit of a quandary for a nation whose education system ranks 21st in science in the world, 25th in math, and first in self-esteem. Translation: We don’t know too much, but we have a helluva strong self-esteem. I guess we feel good about what we don’t know.

And to Maine’s public, beware: Since quoting the U.S. Constitution is in vogue these days, check out designated federal and state powers. To the state is ascribed the function of educating its young (K-12). Here’s the catch: Maine has knowingly and purposely extended that delegation of power to include its colleges.

If you want to exercise your rights, a good place to begin is by examining how higher education has been insidiously folded into K-16 oversight and control, which seeks to assure a one-size-fits-all “product.”

But before we whack away at the pinata of educational reform, we really must return to basics — as in human development and human nature. Overlaying standardized testing on classroom lives harks back to a theme Greg Kesich touched on in his Sept. 22 column.

Kesich was dead on when he connected “unlearned lessons from child development” in the debate “to fix what’s wrong with education.”

What children can do at different ages and stages of their development is the missing hard drive in teach-assess practices that dictate much of contemporary practices.

Advertisement

For example, middle-school students can’t absorb the syntax and semantics of a second language as quickly as 4- to 6-year-olds can. Geographical relationships are likewise linked to brain development.

Children must concretely locate places and regions in order to transfer those images into the brain. Abstract thought about global economic connections will not be intellectually complete otherwise.

Has anyone seriously asked students themselves what works, what doesn’t? How is their learning supported? Not supported? Short-term projects versus expeditionary learning? Group-based or individual rubrics? Teachers who respect their children and dignify their subject matter “read their students” – when to call on someone, when not to; who’s in need of special attention today, perhaps a private, kind word; another 10-minute review of Southeast Asian geography before charging into the day’s lesson plans; or when to stop and start all over.

Yes, teachers can read body language and act on it. Human psychology should guide our day; reams of numerical data should not.

Maine’s five candidates for governor have educational platforms and visions for Maine’s future, and each has elements that are solid, realistic, and understandable to the lay public, i.e., not written in “educationese.”

Democrat Libby Mitchell looks to expand pre-kindergarten to every school and provide grants to high school seniors to attend college.

Advertisement

Republican nominee Paul LePage plans, to his credit, to seriously review the sacred cow of education, special education. Maine’s special education laws exceed federal ones, and a thorough review of this arena is long overdue.

Eliot Cutler’s global understanding of Maine’s future, both nationally and internationally, is highly apparent. An Independent, he also supports alternative paths to education, and a successful boatbuilding school in mid-coast Maine readily comes to mind.

Independent Shawn Moody wants to invest in sound vocational choices for non-college bound high school graduates. Bravo!

Kevin Scott, also an independent, understands that the state’s educational policy must first and foremost engage its teachers.

The American school system mirrors its greater society, and a texting-addicted public, couch-potatoed out watching Jersey Shore, isn’t exactly a shining beacon to its youth.

We all have a hand in making education better. How will you play yours?

 

– Special to The Press Herald

 

Comments are no longer available on this story