ALFRED — Voters here Tuesday will decide whether to spend $75,000 from the capital improvement fund to buy 33.6 acres known as Brother’s Beach, owned by the Brothers of Christian Instruction. They’ll cast ballots 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. at Conant Chapel, adjacent to the Town Hall on Saco Road.
Proponents say it may be the last time the community has a chance to buy the property that fronts on Shaker Pond. Selectmen say they feel the price is a fair one.
Others have raised questions about the price selectmen have offered.
Selectmen had originally entered into a purchase and sale agreement for $125,000 for the property. But the beach is in the Resource Protection Zone, which limits its use, and so selectmen later offered $75,000, and a new deal was struck with the Brothers.
Resident Tony Palminteri, who is also a member of the town’s Budget Board, pointed out that selectmen didn’t seek an appraisal of the property from a real estate professional before making either offer.
Palminteri joined the Budget Committee this year and was at his first meeting when the $125,000 offer was brought up by selectmen. He said it looked to him like the land was in the Resource Protection Zone, and said he felt the price was too steep.
He said he called a real estate appraiser and a broker and they both told him $125,000 was an “exorbitant” price for the land. So, he said he “pushed back” a bit at the next meeting with selectmen. He said the appraiser told him the property was worth about $1,000 an acre.
“My concern is that I believe it is the responsibility of selectmen (to assure) that the people know they’re paying the best possible price – and we don’t know that,” said Palminteri. “My point is we should not pay more than fair market value.”
The budget panel voted 4-3 to in favor of the purchase; Palminteri was among the dissenters.
Selectman George Donovan said the threemember board was guided by the town’s assessed value of the property. One parcel is valued at about $84,500. Another portion is carved out from a larger lot. Donovan pointed out that the Brothers pay about $1,200 in annually in property tax, and a copy of the 2015 tax bill shows that figure, associated with 12 acres of the property.
Donovan said a suggestion that a realtor be asked to provide an appraisal came too late in the process. “We talked to a couple of places and it would have been October,” said Donovan – too late for the Sept. 22 vote.
Selectmen John Sylvester said it is the selectmen’s view that the $75,000 purchase price is well within the value of the land. In a statement forwarded to the Journal Tribune, selectmen claim that because the property contains a buildable lot – even though they say there is no intention to build there – the way the land is valued changes under that circumstance.
“With a home on the property the first acre would be valued at $60,000,” reads the statement, signed by the Board of Selectmen and the study group formed to examine the purchase. “If you were to value the remaining acres at $1,000 per acre … it would bring the total value to $92,000.”
The Brothers approached selectmen about the town buying the property earlier this year. They intend to use the proceeds to help fund new living quarters more suited to the needs of the more elderly members of the order. Ground was broken on that project two weeks ago.
Portions of the beach’s parking lot are within the state’s inland waterfowl wading bird habitat area. While there are no current plans to expand parking, removal of vegetation to expand the existing parking area would require a permit, according to Chris Coppi of the Department of Environmental Protection, who visited the property in late July. His report said access to the swimming area should remain where it currently exists, to limit destruction of vegetation.
Town Attorney Brad Morin and the Maine Municipal Association’s legal counsel say existing activities – swimming and picnicking, canoeing and kayaking and the like – would be allowed to continue through a change of ownership, because the property has been used for that purpose for many years, even though those activities are a non-conforming use.
The opinion from MMA legal counsel states in part that, “So long as the town does not expand the use of the Shaker Pond property, the town has the right to continue the same type of use (passive recreation) that the Brothers of Christian Instruction have allowed.”
The town currently has $500,000 in bonded indebtedness. Treasurer Fred Holt said a lease purchase arrangement for a cardiac monitor will be paid in 2016, a 2013 paving bond will be paid in 2017, and the transfer station bond will be paid in 2020. A purchase of a new, $230,000 ambulance, probably in 2016, is expected to be spread over four years, Holt said. As well, there are plans to renovate some portions of Town Hall.
Funds to pay for the beach would come from the Capital Improvement Fund. Holt said if the buy is approved, the town would replenish that fund over three years, at $25,000 annually, either through taxes or from the undesignated fund.
Donovan said he hopes there is a good turnout of voters.
— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less