2 min read

 
 
George S. Kaufman, a dramatist and journalist who died in 1961, said, “Once upon a time there were three bears: Papa Bear, Mama Bear, and Camembert.”

That’s a pretty cheesy comment, but in this deal, declarer must bear up at trick three. He is in four spades. West leads the heart ace: three, nine, four. West cashes the heart king: six, two, jack. West continues with the heart queen. What should declarer do?

First, South should check his losers. He seems to have only three: two in hearts and one in clubs. But he must also worry about that third heart. East has played high-low, indicating a doubleton. Yes, he might be fooling, but what if he is not? Then he is threatening to overruff the dummy at trick three and give declarer an extra loser.

At trick three, South has four dummy choices: ruff low, ruff middle, ruff high, or discard. Which should he choose?

As I am confident you have worked out by now, the second-best play is to ruff with dummy’s spade nine. Maybe West has the 10. Here, though, East overruffs and the contract goes down one.

Advertisement

Instead, declarer should discard one of dummy’s clubs. In this way, he trades a dangerous ruff in hearts for a much safer ruff in clubs.

Suppose West shifts to a club. South wins with dummy’s ace (the honor from the shorter side first), draws two rounds of trumps, cashes his club king, ruffs his last club in the dummy, plays a diamond to his ace, draws East’s third trump, and claims.

If an opponent may objectionably overruff, consider shedding an inevitable loser.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.