2 min read

 
 
Charles Ruff, a lawyer who defended president Bill Clinton, said, “Impeachment is not a remedy for private wrongs; it’s a method of removing someone whose continued presence in office would cause grave danger to the nation.”

A bridge player could rewrite that as: Ruffing or overruffing is not always a remedy for making or breaking a contract; each deal must be taken on its own merits.

In today’s deal, South is in four hearts. West starts the defense with three rounds of diamonds. East plays highlow, then ruffs dummy’s queen with the heart 10. What should declarer do?

It is unappealing to open one club with only three low cards in the suit, but with 13 high-card points, one cannot pass. (For those of you who use the Support Double, North’s two-heart rebid guarantees four-card support. With only three hearts, North would double over two diamonds.)

South, assuming trumps are not 4-0, seems to have only three losers: two diamonds and one club. It looks easy to overruff at trick three, draw trumps, and claim. Here, though, there is a nasty surprise waiting for declarer. He suddenly finds that he has a trump loser and goes down one.

Advertisement

South should realize that whatever happens, he will lose a club trick – so why not concede it now? Instead of overruffing, declarer should discard his club eight. Then everything is under control.

Don’t overruff when it might result in an opponent gaining a trump trick and you have an inevitable loser to discard.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.