2 min read

SANFORD — Secretary of State Matthew Dunlap said Tuesday that a balloting discrepancy in the House District 19 special election on Nov. 3 was due to human error. He said there is no evidence of any fraudulent intent.

When voters from District 18 and District 19 were casting ballots at the Ward 1 Nasson Community Center polling place on Election Day, election clerks mistakenly handed out District 19 ballots without confirming that each voter resided in District 19, according to a prepared statement issued by Dunlap Tuesday afternoon.

Sanford City Clerk Sue Cote noticed the error early on Election Day; in an earlier interview she said she noticed the mistake prior to 10 a.m. The polls opened at 8 a.m. that day.

The mix-up with the ballots was not enough to change the outcome of the vote, Dunlap noted. Republican Matthew Harrington was declared the winner in a recount Friday, besting Democratic candidate Jean Noon by 13 votes; one less than the original result.

Eleven residents of District 18 were identified as having voted before the ballot distribution error was noticed. Voting records show a difference of eight ballots, with 813 voters’ names checked off as having voted in District 19, but 821 ballots actually cast in the District 19 race.

Advertisement

Maine Republican Party Chairman Rick Bennett and Executive Director Jason Savage issued a news release during the re-count, alleging former state senator John Tuttle, who lives in a different district, improperly cast a ballot in the District 19 race.

Tuttle, who lives in District 18, told the Journal Tribune on Friday that he hadn’t cast a ballot for the District 19 race between Democrat Jean Noon and Republican Matthew Harrington.

“I didn’t have the Harrington-Noon ballot,” he said. “I didn’t have it at all.”

As well, Maine Democratic Party Executive Director Jeremy Kennedy said the party was “deeply concerned” about voting irregularities that took place in Sanford on Election Day.

“It is impossible to know how many District 18 voters actually received the ballot in error, how many may have noticed the error and chose not the cast the ballot, or if election clerks simply failed to check off the names of some District 19 voters who cast ballots,” according to the Secretary of State’s news release.

Despite training sessions for election clerks and special efforts made to differentiate the districts on the incoming voter list, such as increased font size, it is clear that some voters did improperly receive the District 19 ballot, the news release noted.

Advertisement

“The stakes are high in any election, so any concern about the conduct of ballot procedures is something we take very seriously,” said Dunlap. “In our review of the circumstances around the District 19 special election, while some human error was introduced into the process, no criminal conduct occurred.”

— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.