
He said he’ll consider resigning if York County Commissioners agree to fund the probate judge’s position on a full- time basis.
Nadeau made his initial pronouncement following denial of motions Tuesday in a civil case brought by a New Hampshire grandmother in November. In the class action suit, Renee LeGrand claims changes that Nadeau made to his part-time schedule resulted in the loss of temporary custody of her granddaughter.
Nadeau had filed motions seeking dismissal of the case, claiming immunity as a judge. He also asked for a ruling that York County government pay for an attorney to represent him in the case.; Nadeau is currently representing himself.
Cumberland County Superior Court Justice Thomas Warren denied the motions on Tuesday.
This morning, Nadeau confirmed he made the resignation comment following Tuesday’s hearing. He laid out his terms in an email sent Tuesday evening to county attorney Gene Libby and lawyers involved in the civil case, which he also emailed to the Journal Tribune.
“I will consider resigning from my office as I indicated to Justice Warren this afternoon so that you can install a replacement Independent candidate of your liking,” he said in the email, “if but only if the Commissioners will first agree to fund the new judge’s position as a full-time position with comprehensive legal defense insurance coverage as to any form of administrative and litigation claim filed against him/her whenever it may be needed, consistent with the level of funding of state court judges and with the actual needs of the York Probate Court, and with the understanding that the county and its manager will support, not any longer oppose, the judge’s canonized and statutory duties to supervise the work of the probate register and staff and his associated directives.”
“If my resignation is what it will take to convince you (Libby) and the Commissioners to properly and adequately fund the needs of the families, children, adult incapacitated and other persons dependent upon an overburdened York County Probate Court for service and to properly support the county’s probate judge, whomever he or she may be, then that is what I am willing to do,” he further wrote.
In the email, Nadeau also said he has contacted York County Register of Probate Carol Lovejoy about the feasibility and potential timetable of him returning to his former schedule. He described Lovejoy as “uninformed” and “self serving,” and said he will support her opponent in her upcoming bid for re-election. Lovejoy has worked for the Registry of Probate for 35 years; 12 as register.
For the full text of Nadea’s email, see below.
In Maine, probate judges are elected and typically hold court on a part-time basis. Many probate judges also maintain private law practices.
Nadeau earns about $54,000 annually as a parttime probate judge. He holds court two days a week, or 64 hours a month. He has previously said he regularly spends 90 hours a month dealing with probate work, but is only paid for 64 hours.
Nadeau changed his schedule from holding court on Wednesdays and Thursdays to Mondays and Fridays in April, hours after York County Commissioners denied his request for a $90,000 salary and a three-day-per-week schedule, or $120,000 for five days a week.
Commissioners claim Nadeau changed his schedule in retaliation for their denial of his request, and held a hearing to that effect in October. The matter is also under scrutiny by the Maine Committee on Judicial Responsibility and Disability following a complaint to that agency by the county.
County Manager Greg Zinser said this morning that Nadeau’s indication that he might resign is “nothing new.”
“The judge is recognizing his actions have consequences, and his motions and posturing do not have the merit he thinks they do,” said Zinser. “What we’re seeing with this latest offer is simply more games. It is the action of an individual trying to figure it out as he goes along. This is nothing new.”
Nadeau served as the county’s probate judge from about 1997 to 2008. He lost the 2008 election, but was elected in November 2012 for a four-year term that began in January 2013.
Nadeau is awaiting a decision from the Maine Supreme Judicial Court on different charges brought by the Committee on Judicial Responsibility and Disability. Those charges allege that Nadeau violated five provisions of the judicial code, including compromising the integrity of the judiciary and demeaning a district court judge. Oral arguments in that case were heard Nov. 4.
Nadeau has a history of being rebuked by the courts.
Nadeau was censured by the Maine Supreme Judicial for misrepresenting the contents of a videotaped advertisement involving his opponent in the 2004 primary.
In 2006, in a case heard by the Board of Overseers of the Bar, he was reprimanded in connection with his private law practice for a critical letter he wrote to a Superior Court justice who had declined to seal records in a civil suit filed by his former law practice colleagues, and for continuing to send correspondence to them. A third charge of having an intimate relationship with a client was dismissed with a warning.
— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.
This is an email Robert Nadeau sent to York County Attorney Gene Libby and other attorneys Tuesday. He also emailed it directly to the the Journal Tribune:
Mr. Libby,
Please confirm by tomorrow at 5 PM whether you will accept service of trial subpoenas I will be issuing to Commissioners Chandler, Dutremble and Cote, and to Mr. Zinser, for their attendance and testimony at the upcoming trial. I will otherwise have them served by alternative means. Please also advise as to whether they will require statutory travel and attendance fees.
In the meantime, I have inquired of Register Lovejoy as to the feasibility of and a possible timetable associated with any switch back to the former Wednesday-Thursday schedule. Such a schedule was woefully inadequate to give me the means as a judge to attempt to most efficiently address emergency hearing and trial needs, although it did afford me more free time after hours due to the resulting reduced need to find afterhours time to research and write trial decisions because fewer trials were heard under that former system.
The schedule I reverted to this past Spring was and would clearly be, in my considered experience, far more responsive to the needs of the users of the York County Probate Court. However, until Ms. Lovejoy is hopefully replaced in the general election by her opponent I will be supporting under the circumstances, it seems very clear that you and she, Mr. Zinser and apparently Mr. Mittel, none of whom have the authority to run the probate court and none of whom really understand its needs as well as I, will nevertheless be running the probate court as you have collectively attempted to do during the past 3 years. I will simply continue to appear and provide my dedicated time and effort on designated court days within the constraints of the scheduling system that preceded my return to office until a new Register who can work with me comes on board at the end of the year so that hopefully much better public service can thereafter be delivered.
As a separate matter, I will consider resigning from my office as I indicated to Justice Warren this afternoon so that you can install a replacement Independent candidate of your liking, if but only if the Commissioners will first agree to fund the new judge’s position as a full-time position with comprehensive legal defense insurance coverage as to any form of administrative and litigation claim filed against him/her whenever it may be needed, consistent with the level of funding of state court judges and with the actual needs of the York Probate Court, and with the understanding that the county and its manager will support, not any longer oppose, the judge’s canonized and statutory duties to supervise the work of the probate register and staff and his associated directives.
I make this offer notwithstanding Register Lovejoy’s uniformed and, frankly, very self-serving understanding of those needs to the contrary. If my resignation is what it will take to convince you and the Commissioners to properly and adequately fund the needs of the families, children, adult incapacitated and other persons dependent upon an overburdened York County Probate Court for service and to properly support the county’s probate judge, whomever he or she may be, then that is what I am willing to do. It matters much less who the judge of the court is than it matters that the judge and the people who depend upon the court for timely hearings will have the support necessary from the county to enable the judge to do his/her job on a full-time basis with a proper level of support. It is, thus, now time for the 5 commissioners—Chandler, Dutremble and Lovell, as well as the two up for re-election this year, namely, Sinden and Cote—to demonstrate their commitment to all of their constituents dependent upon the York County Probate Court for service.
Proper funding should not be a problem for the County. It has a chairwoman, Ms. Chandler, with a mere high school diploma being paid $141.01/hour for her 3 hours or less of public service at biweekly meetings, and four other commissioners of varying educational levels receiving $134.13/hr.; a new county manager who is paid $119,324 per year and has the support of a Finance Director being paid $88,903/yr. and an HR Director being paid $75,245/yr. for a total manager-related tab to the taxpayers of $283,472 when in 2008 all 3 jobs were performed by a county manager paid just slightly more than $70,000 per year with no Finance Director and no HR Director to help him; and you, as the county’s attorney, probably charging the county $20,000 to $30,000 in this pending litigation, just to resist my efforts to get more help for the probate court from those very same people.
Robert M.A. Nadeau, Esq.
Nadeau Legal PLLC
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less