
The music of two very different composers was on the program, namely Beethoven representing the early 19th century and the classic approach to symphonic writing, paired with Richard Strauss representing the expressionist style of the late l9th and early 20th century. In remarks to the audience at the start of the concert, Moody suggested that the four excerpts by Strauss, taken from three different operas, could be thought of as a symphonic work. (Frankly, I think that this was stretching things to make a point. The first three excerpts, perhaps, but not the concluding work, which was in another galaxy “far, far away.”)
The work by Beethoven (part of the performance of all nine Beethoven symphonies by the PSO) is the most tightly wrought and classic symphony by that master. It is frequently overlooked, coming as it does between the classic-romantic seventh symphony and the monumental ninth, the latter symphony which changed everything.
Moody gave it an exiting and emotional performance, which was also lyrical where it needed to be. The work is full of demonic booby traps even for experienced players. For example, in three-fourths time the third beat is usually soft with the first, the accented beat frequently loud. Beethoven reverses this. Then there are brief flirtations with unrelated keys, sudden stops, pauses and unexpected soft and quick phrases of important ideas. Simply put, Beethoven is deliberately playing havoc with what was anticipated while at the same time turning out a work that is tightly classic in an architectural sense. He didn’t use or need a large orchestra to do this, simply winds in pairs, trumpets and horns and timpani. But oh, how imaginatively he used his forces. The winds in particular were marvelous in the third movement and while the last movement started out a tad too fast, things settled down quickly to a tempo that seemed just right.
After intermission, Strauss was given his due. His was a long and varied career. He started out trying to write in the classic-romantic style of Brahms. He soon was convinced to try a different approach, namely the creation of tone poems; that is, music which described events and/or told a story. Among the many he wrote, music lovers should recognize the names of “Don Juan,” “Don Quizote,” “Ein Heldenleben,” “Till Eulenspiegel,” and “Also Sprach Zarathustra” (the latter used to good effect in the film “2001: A Space Opera.”) He decided to turn his attention to opera, unhappily either writing or selecting stories that would receive an X or R rating even then. The first selection came from the opera Gunstram, relatively brief and which recalled to this listener the “2001” theme. The second selection was the love theme, (finale) from “Feursnot,” which decency prevents me from describing the story. The last two excerpts came from “Salome.” The story concerns Salome, who, being spurned by John the Baptist, danced for King Herod (“Dance of the Seven Veils,” each one revealing more until there was nothing left to reveal) and finally the finale, where the young lady asked for and received the severed head of John and proceeds to fondle and kiss it. This was too much even for Herod, and he had her killed.
“The Dance” received a rousing and spirited performance. Racette then came on stage to sing a part that only someone with the endurance of an Olympian and tonsils to match could sing. Her powerful, steely soprano cut through the thick orchestration of Strauss with ease. (The instrumentation was not listed, but if it could make a sound, it was there.) The text was superimposed on both sides of the stage, a wonderful aid to understanding what the soloist was screaming about. Her performance of this music was magnificent, as was the conducting of Moody and the performance of the members of the PSO. Members who had solo parts were recognized amidst the standing ovation this performance merited. The concert will be broadcast on Maine Public Radio at 8 p.m. on Feb. 10, but you will have to get your own libretto.
— Dr. Gold is a composer/conductor, retired educator and an arts reviewer for the Journal Tribune.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less