
That is the start of a famous quote from former Indianapolis Colts coach Jim Mora. While Mora was talking about how his team was struggling and should only be worried about winning another game — that outburst comes to mind every time I think about the College Football Playoff.
I’m a huge college football fan. Actually, unlike probably 99-percent of people living in New England, I would much rather sit and watch college football all day than the National Football League.
That is why it pisses me off every year a college football season ends without an actual playoff being held.
For those of you that don’t know, the “College Football Playoff” is a 4-team field that is determined by a 13-member committee made up of former coaches and current college athletic directors.
While this system is slightly better than the former Bowl Championship Series model, which was based on polls and computer selection methods, it still denies a lot of teams a chance to actually play for a national title.
The perfect example is the University of Central Florida Knights, who went through this entire season without a loss but since they play in a lower-level conference they were left out of the committee’s final four.
I agreed with the CFP committee that despite UCF’s record, they were not among the best four teams in the country. They simply had not played anyone all year that truly showed they could compete with the eventual final four teams (Alabama, Clemson, Georgia and Oklahoma) or even teams that didn’t make the “playoff,” like Ohio State, Wisconsin or Penn State.
But I do feel that UCF deserved a chance to prove they belonged on the game’s biggest stage — and they pretty much proved that in their bowl game.
UCF was matched up with SEC powerhouse Auburn, which just happened to beat both Alabama and Georgia — the two teams who will meet for the national title — in the regular season. The Knights knocked off Auburn by a 34-27 score in the Peach Bowl on New Year’s Day to finish with a perfect 13-0 record.
I think there is one very simple solution to this problem: Expand the College Football Playoff to eight teams.
It seems like a no-brainer to me. You put the champions of the five major conferences — ACC, Big 10, Big 12, Pac 12 and SEC — in the playoff and then have three spots for wild cards. If a team like UCF who plays in what the NCAA calls a Group of Five conference (AAC, Conference USA, MAC, Sun Belt and Mountain West) is undefeated you give them a spot in the playoff. That would leave two spots for teams from the Power Five conferences that didn’t win their league title.
If there is no undefeated team from the Group of Five, that would obviously open up another spot for a Power Five school, which also includes independents like Notre Dame and Army.
The big argument against expanding the current “playoff,” is that it would diminish what is now the best regular season in all of sports. People love that every game in college football’s regular season means a ton. That’s because, currently, if you end up losing two, or even one game, there’s a chance you won’t make the final four.
That argument is just plain wrong.
Even if you expand to eight teams, the regular season will still mean more than it does in any other sport.
Look at a team like Penn State, who lost just two games — by a combined four points — this season and finished at 10-2. The Nittany Lions actually finished the regular season ranked ninth in the Associated Press poll, which means they more than likely would have been left out of the new eight-team playoff.
So how could anyone say the regular season wouldn’t matter as much in an eight-team playoff system?
Every other form of college football — from Division III to the Football Championship Subdivision (or D1AA) — has a large postseason tournament. FCS has a 24-team field, while Division II has a 28-team playoff and Division III puts 32 teams into the bracket.
So why is the biggest division in college football forced to let a committee, who lets face it has to have some biases, select only four teams to have a shot at a national title.
It just doesn’t make sense — and until they expand to at least eight teams, they should stop calling it a “playoff.”
— Sports Editor Pat McDonald can be reached at pmcdonald@journaltribune.com or at 282-1535 ext. 322. Follow the Journal Tribune Sports Department on Twitter @JournalTsports.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less