MONTPELIER, Vt. — Nearly every day, somewhere in the country, the Stars and Stripes was lowered to half-staff last year in one of the most significant official gestures of mourning and respect, an Associated Press analysis found.
The centuries-old practice can be a visible, public answer to extraordinary loss, as when more than four dozen people were killed last month at a gay nightclub in Florida. But as the nation marks Independence Day on Monday, flag buffs have noted that the honor has been extended more widely over time, including to celebrities and police dogs. And some have questioned whether the country has lowered the bar on the lowering of the flag.
“It can be a very powerful symbol, but it can also be overdone to the point that it loses its significance,” said John Hartvigsen, president of the North American Vexillological Association, a flag aficionados’ group. “You can’t spell everything out about this in rules and regulations, because it has so much to do with emotion.”
Federal law allows presidents and governors to lower the flags to honor the fallen or people who have died after long lives of service. The flag can also be lowered on certain holidays.
And in some cases governors can order the lowering of the state flag.
An analysis by The Associated Press found that on nearly 90 percent of days last year, one or more states were flying the American flag at half-staff to memorialize the deaths of military members, public officials, police, first responders, prominent citizens and victims of mass killings and disasters.
Eight states had orders lowering the U.S. flag in effect over more than 30 days; Massachusetts led all others, keeping the flag at half-staff for over a quarter of the year, including on the Fourth of July.
Among the hundreds honored were victims of extremist attacks, fallen soldiers, long-serving politicians and such celebrities as baseball legend Yogi Berra.
Those honored last year alone with a half-staff U.S. flag include five Georgia Southern University nursing students killed in a car wreck and a Downey, California, police officer shot in his car in a police parking lot in an alleged robbery attempt. Flags were lowered for a Missouri state official who was running for governor when he killed himself after a radio ad mocked his appearance, and for an Oklahoma state road worker who died helping to fill a sinkhole. One honoree was a police dog shot in Ohio.
Who gets honored, and when, can be controversial. Recent years saw tension over lowering flags nationwide for former South African President Nelson Mandela and in New Jersey for the Grammy-winning Whitney Houston.
Although Massachusetts may lead the nation in flag lowering, the three states of northern New England were more selective in choosing when to lower the flag, doing so for a total of 10 times last year, including for the death of a former Vermont governor, a New Hampshire police officer killed in the line of duty and three Mainers who died in the sinking of the cargo ship El Faro.
The lowering of the flag ordered by state officials in Vermont, New Hampshire in Maine are in addition to presidential proclamations that lead to lowering the flag.
An Associated Press analysis of proclamations from 50 state governors and the federal government found the Stars and Stripes were lowered at least someplace in the country on 328 days during 2015.
Last year, Democratic Vermont Gov. Peter Shumlin ordered the American flag lowered to honor the death of former Gov. F. Ray Keyser Jr. But in Vermont, the state flag was lowered on three additional occasions to commemorate the death of Trooper Kyle Young, who was killed in a training accident, former Lt. Gov. Barbara Snelling and the shooting death of social worker Lara Sobel, who was allegedly shot by a disgruntled client.
In New Hampshire, flags were lowered for the state law enforcement officers’ memorial ceremony in Concord, with a special recognition of Brentwood Police Officer Stephen Arkell. In 2014, he responded to a domestic violence call, and when he was invited into the home, he was immediately gunned down by 47-year-old Michael Nolan, who had been arguing with his father. Nolan then set the house ablaze, killing himself. After an explosion, the building burned to the ground.
Arkell’s name is etched on the state memorial, the 46th to be added to the monument for fallen officers.
In addition, the flag in New Hampshire was lowered for Navy Seal William Blake Marston and U.S. Army Ranger Andrew A. Aimesbury, both of whom died in training exercises, and for the victims of the Chattanooga shooting.
In Maine, Gov. Paul LePage ordered the flags lowered four times for the victims of a shooting at a Chattanooga military installation and for Michael Lee Holland, Danielle Randolph, and Dylan Meklin, all Mainers who died in the sinking of the cargo ship El Faro.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less