3 min read

BIDDEFORD — Officials with the Charter Review Commission on Thursday defended their decision to present voters with a six-question ballot regarding changes to the city’s charter in November, a decision that was highly contested by some city officials at Tuesday night’s City Council meeting.

The commission presented a proposed six-section ballot to councilors on Tuesday, which would go before voters in the Nov. 8 general election. Some city councilors took issue with the limited number of questions on the ballot, which grouped proposed changes to the charter into six categories.

“We’ve always had separate questions. I don’t care if there’s 20 of them. People should have the right to vote for individual questions, and if they don’t, it’s a disservice to this community,” said Councilor Rick Laverriere on Tuesday. “That’s a total disservice to the city, of people not voting for every question, and if that’s going to stay, I’m going to push very hard to have everything voted down.”

The proposed ballot includes questions regarding establishing a residency requirement for both the city manager and school superintendent unless otherwise approved by city council (currently, there is no exception to the residency requirement); compensation for city councilors and school committee members; removal of the police and fire commissions and the subsequent establishment of police and fire advisory committees; and powers of the mayor and City Council.

The proposed ballot also includes a section for “other proposed revisions,” which outlines 13 recommended revisions such as the establishment of a five-year capital improvement program for the city and development of a code of ethics for the City Council. This section garnered the most opposition from council members.

Advertisement

Charter Revision Commission Chairman Paul Therrien said Thursday that the categorized ballot already strays from state statute, which requires that charter revisions be grouped into one question for voters.

“In the beginning, we were following the state statute that says when you do a revision, you do one question and you ask the voting public to agree or disagree with the changes that we are recommending,” Therrien said in an interview. “We have a total of about 30 recommended changes. … We thought maybe that, even though the law says to do it that way, maybe we should categorize it into five categories, with the remainder into one question.”

According to Maine Revised Statutes MRSA Title 30-A, 2105, voters are to be asked in one question if they approve all changes recommended by a charter commission for revisions to city charters.

“The law was written like that to reflect that voter’s confidence and trust in the Charter Review Commission that the voters elected,” Therrien said in an emailed statement. “It is unfair to ask the voters to decide in 2 minutes or less, what took the Charter Review Commission 6 months.”

On Tuesday, Councilor Bob Mills asked Therrien if sufficient information would be provided with each question on the ballot to inform voters about exactly what they would be voting for or against, but ultimately expressed dissatisfaction with the commission’s approach.

“I still believe, like Councilor Laverriere, it’s a disservice to the community, because some people may not read these thoroughly,” Mills said. “We’ll debate it later.”

Advertisement

Therrien said he met with Laverriere on Thursday evening to discuss the councilor’s issues with the proposed ballot, saying the two had not resolved their dispute but had discussed a variety of options, which Therrien was not at liberty to discuss.

“It was a good meeting, so we thought maybe we would have a chance to better understand why he feels as strongly as he does to have 30 questions on the ballot,” Therrien said. “…I’m still convinced that the best option is one question. But I have no issue whatsoever with going along with the majority of the commission, and that’s what they want, and that’s fine.”

Therrien stressed that none of the proposed charter revisions or ballot formats are finalized. Further changes to both the charter and the ballot may be brought forward in the future.

“We’re not planted in cement yet,” he said.

A public hearing about the proposed charter revisions will take place at 7 p.m. Thursday in the Council Chambers.

— Staff Writer Alan Bennett can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or abennett@journaltribune.com.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.