3 min read

Alfred Selectman Tony Palminteri and Alfred Parish Church trustee Steve MacKinnon stand in the old cemetery that separates the church building from Alfred Town Hall. Ownership of the cemetery had been unresolved for years, but now the entities say they’ve found the answer. TAMMY WELLS/Journal Tribune

ALFRED — Morgan Lewis served as a major in one regiment and a captain another in the Revolutionary War. He died on Nov. 17, 1784, at age 47 of blood poisoning, after encountering a rusty nail helping build the Alfred Parish Church several months before, according to local legend.

Documents on file at the Maine Historical Society say Lewis was the first person buried in what was described as the Alfred village cemetery — the old burial ground that separates what is now Alfred Town Hall and the adjacent congregational church, known as Alfred Parish Church, UCC.

For years, neither the town or the church knew precisely who owned the old cemetery, though the town assumed maintenance costs many years ago.

Efforts to determine the ownership over the years faltered, until recently.

“I’ve been working on this for seven years,” said Steve MacKinnon, a church trustee. “It’s been unsolved for 100 years,” said Selectman Tony Palminteri. “The selectmen and the church tried to reach a resolution.”

Advertisement

Past efforts came to naught. But debris from the large maple trees at the front of the cemetery had begun to fall on cars parked there, and that prompted a call to the town’s insurance company. After some research, said Palminteri, the insurance company noted the unresolved ownership, told the town to come up with a plan of action and mandated the parking lot be cordoned off in the meantime.

Calls were made to Town Historian Bruce Tucker and surveyor Dana Libby and, said Palminteri, the two compared notes. “They came to the same conclusion. There is no documentation that exists anywhere that suggested the cemetery was the church’s property,” said Palminteri.

“It also served the Baptist church,” said MacKinnon of the cemetery. As well, MacKinnon said, in the early 1800s, Alfred leased a piece of land — now the informal parking lot in front of the cemetery — to build a school. “That is a clincher,” said MacKinnon that further reinforces the town’s ownership.

Tucker pointed out that in a community’s early days, a parish church was also the seat of government.

So why was it important to find the answer? And what is the next step?

“It is important to do so because of liability — and the church is financially struggling,” said MacKinnon.

Advertisement

Alfred pays about $3,500 annually to maintain the cemetery.

Selectmen and trustees forged an agreement. Alfred, pending approval by those voting at Town Meeting on Saturday, will give the church a right of way into the cemetery and a easement so they can access the back of the church for maintenance. No money will change hands, said Palminteri.

In addition, under the agreement, the town can give the church permission to hold a burial at the cemetery under special conditions. With the exception of the burial of the ashes of a long time pastor, no burials have taken place at the cemetery for many years.

The Town Meeting is set for 10 a.m. Saturday at Alfred Elementary School.

— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com. t

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.