2 min read

 
 
You surely know the answer to the riddle, “When is a door not a door?”

In bridge, when is a trick not a trick?

Well, I suppose a trick is always a trick, but sometimes the time when a trick is taken can be critical – as in this deal. South is in four spades. After West leads the heart ace, what should happen?

West’s two-heart overcall was thin, but potentially told partner what to lead and possibly made life difficult for the responder if he lacked spade support. North made a modern cue-bid raise to show at least game-invitational values with three or more spades. (If you do not use this gadget, North would respond three spades.)

At trick one, East plays the heart two under his partner’s ace. If this is a singleton, West should continue the suit, but that is improbable. It cannot be from a doubleton, because East would have started a high-low. Most likely is that East started with a tripleton. So many a West would hasten to cash the heart king, but that would let the contract make. South would discard his club jack on dummy’s heart queen.

Advertisement

Can West’s second heart trick disappear?

No, it cannot. So West should shift to a top-of-nothing club nine. (If East has the diamond ace, that trick won’t run away, either.) South takes East’s queen with his ace, cashes the spade ace (West needs the king for his overcall), then leads his other heart, but West takes that trick and plays a second club, or first cashes the heart king before leading the club.

A door isn’t a door when it is ajar.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.