3 min read

Pepperell Square in downtown Saco, as seen Thursday afternoon.
Pepperell Square in downtown Saco, as seen Thursday afternoon.
SACO — The message from downtown business owners was clear Thursday afternoon – closing Pepperell Square to traffic would be bad for business.

City Administrator Kevin Sutherland held a meeting with business owners at City Hall Thursday after his proposal to temporarily halt vehicle traffic in the square drew opposition.

Sutherland proposed that the town close Pepperell Square to traffic for a week in October – except for early morning deliveries – and install a pop-up pedestrian plaza. He said the temporary closing was suggested by a traffic engineer hired by the city to measure the impact it would have on downtown traffic, and was part of an overall traffic management plan for the city.

Pepperell Square is an area of downtown off Main Street via Front Street. Sutherland said the traffic light on Main Street and Pepperell Square backs up traffic, and the city wanted to get better traffic flow on Main Street.

Sutherland’s proposal was discussed at a Sept. 22 Traffic Safety Committee meeting, but was tabled due to pushback from local business owners.

Advertisement

A letter was sent to building owners prior to the September meeting, but many of the downtown business owners said they were unaware of the proposal until after the meeting was held. Thursday’s meeting was meant to get feedback from local business owners.

“I made the mistake of not reaching out to this group first,” said Sutherland. “That’s on me, no one else.”

Sutherland said the proposal was tabled until spring so that the city could get more feedback from the Pepperell Square business community.

Fausto Pifferer, owner of Blue Elephant Catering, said it was impossible to limit deliveries to the morning, and that closing the square would impact his livelihood.

“You should just kill it,” he said.

Planning Board member Don Girouard said he brought the proposal before the Planning Board in February. His position now is the same as it was then, he said: the city needs to be sensitive to the needs of the Pepperell Square business owners.

Advertisement

“I’m really heartened with the turnout today,” said Girouard. “This is the process at its best.”

Girouard said one of the ideas behind the pedestrian park was that it would help draw people to the area and give them a place to congregate downtown. He asked the crowd if the idea would work, and a show of hands made clear the majority of the 60 or so people in the audience thought it would not.

Johanna Hoffman, manager of Saco Frame Center, said many of the businesses in the square, like hers, were a “destination” business. A pedestrian park wouldn’t help business, but hinder it by eliminating parking, she said.

Hoffman was also concerned that taking the traffic light out of the Pepperell Square intersection would speed traffic through downtown. She suggested the city use Jubilee Park, an underutilized public park on a small island off Water Street that is accessible by a covered pedestrian bridge, as a downtown gathering place and a location to hold events.

Hoffman and other business owners said they thought traffic problems in the downtown were seasonal, and that most were brought on by trains stopping traffic.

Jeff Brochu, an electrician who does service calls in Pepperell Square, said backup on Main Street was caused by the Amtrak Downeaster going through the city, as the train triggers all the area traffic lights to go to red.

Advertisement

Brochu suggested the city eliminate the left turn lane from Front Street to Main Street and have Biddefordbound traffic move instead over Water Street to Elm Street, where it could pass over to Biddeford and avoid train traffic.

Gail Summey, owner of Illusions Salon, said she was concerned her elderly customers wouldn’t be able to find parking close enough to her salon if the square was closed down.

“There are so many questions that are up in the air and unanswered,” she said.

Sutherland said he would review the input from the meeting, and would also meet with railroad officials to discuss possible changes that could positively impact traffic flow. He is scheduled to meet with business owners again on Oct. 20.

— Staff Writer Liz Gotthelf can be contacted at 282-1535, Ext. 325 or egotthelf@journaltribune.com.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.