3 min read

Most York County school administrators were displeased with their school district’s “grades,” released late last week by the governor and education commissioner.

The A-F scale was based mostly on test scores, and the average for schools statewide was a C, while 31 percent of the state’s high schools received a D or an F, according to the Associated Press.

Elementary schools were graded on the results of math and reading assessment tests, and improvement in those scores year to year among all students and among the lowest 25 percent. High schools were graded using math and reading assessment tests and growth in those scores as well as graduation rates, according to the Associated Press.

Locally, Regional School Unit 21 fared the best, with As for Kennebunk High School, Middle School of the Kennebunks and the Mildred L. Day School in Arundel, and B grades for Kennebunkport Consolidated School and the Sea Road School in Kennebunk.

Administrators in many districts said the grades are not helpful as they do not offer any guidance to school leaders, nor do they consider anything besides test scores.

Advertisement

RSU 21 Superintendent Andrew Dolloff pointed out the grade only takes into account instruction in math and reading, adding that high-performing school districts generally have three characteristics: Dedicated and talented staff, a motivated student body, and a supportive, well-educated community.

Other superintendents pointed out the correlation between high grades and per pupil spending.

Wells-Ogunquit Community School District Interim Superintendent Bill Richards said the correlation between good letter grades and districts with the highest per pupil spending shows the lack of equity in the grading system. Wells High School and Wells Junior High received B grades, while Wells Elementary School got a C.

Patrick Phillips, superintendent of Regional School Unit 23, agreed, noting that while Old Orchard Beach High School has about 48 percent of students who qualify for free or reduced lunch ”“ about average for the state ”“ the school received a B grade, which is above average.

Phillips said Education Commissioner Stephen Bowen should identify schools that have achieved higher than others in the same poverty index and determine what it is these schools are doing to support students.

RSU 57 Superintendent Dr. John Davis said the system is not fair because the grading is based on a bell curve, and very few schools have a chance at making an A. One school would have to knock another school down to a lower grade to move into a higher position, Davis said, and he would have advocated instead for a standards-based approach so that all schools could reach the A level.

Advertisement

Massabesic High School received a D, while a grade of C was given to Massabesic Middle School, Shapleigh Memorial School, Waterboro Elementary, Lyman Elementary and Line School. Alfred Elementary got an A.

Davis said the D ranking for MHS was due to the testing participation rate being less than two-tenths of a point lower than what they would need for a C grade. Davis said he was “greatly disappointed” in the governor and particularly the education commissioner, who he said “knows better,” but lacked the leadership to tell the governor that this was the wrong approach.

“I hope the next governor who comes through will have the wisdom and leadership to say, ”˜no, this is not an effective way of identifying success,’” Davis said.

School leaders are right to question this system, and we hope Gov. Paul LePage and Education Commissioner Bowen will reconsider their approach in evaluating school districts.

While testing is an important component of schooling and measuring students’ progress, it is far from the only characteristic that should be considered in such an important process.

Maine’s new grading system is reportedly based on the Florida model, where high-performing schools received a bonus, but throwing more money at high-performing, well-funded school districts will not help the districts that are struggling and falling behind. Districts are not even getting the 55 percent funding commitment from the state they are supposed to now.

Evaluating student performance ”“ and school and teacher performance ”“ should be a multi-pronged approach, considering more than just test scores and graduation rates. School funding should not be taken away or given to districts based solely on test performance, rather schools that are high-performing should share their successful programs with schools with lower performance ratings to give all schools the best chance to succeed.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.