3 min read

OLD ORCHARD BEACH — A controversial ordinance change was voted down by the Old Orchard Beach Town Council after a resident had a surprising change of heart and pleaded with the council to oppose it.

On Tuesday, The council unanimously voted to oppose an ordinance change that would have allowed a contractor yard operating at a larger scale than is currently allowed in the rural district. The rural district includes parcels of one acre or more with road frontage along Portland Avenue between the intersection of Ross Road and Portland Avenue and the Scarborough town line.

Contractor Yard 2 businesses are allowed in the rural zone, and the proposed ordinance change would have allowed Contractor Yard 1 businesses as well.

The Contractor Yard 2 category includes businesses conducted by a single person with no more than two constuction or commercial vehicles and does not allow fueling storage tanks.

The Contractor Yard 1 category allows for businesses with more than two commercial or construction vehicles and fuel storage facilities up to 10,000 gallons. Contractor Yard 1 businesses can also have employees.

The proposed ordinance change to allow Contractor Yard 1 ordinances was reviewed earlier this year by the Planning Board, which recommended the town oppose the change.

Advertisement

The issue was brought to the town’s attention by Walter Murphy, a Portland Avenue resident and neighbor of Debbie MacDonald, who runs MacDonald’s Excavation in the rural district at 169 Portland Ave.

Attorney Gene Libby, representing Murphy, stated in a letter written to the town last month that MacDonald’s excavation has been operating in violation of town ordinance for years and there are “intense industrial uses” occurring at MacDonald’s property, including the storage of trucks, heavy equipment and materials.

Attorney Harry Center, representing MacDonald, said in a phone interview last week that MacDonald’s Excavation is “a perfectly legal and appropriate” business in the rural district that’s been operating for many years. He said it does not disrupt the character of the rural area, where other businesses, including another excavation business, a hardscaping business and an auto repair service are located.

Sharri MacDonald, Debbie’s sister, gave an emotional statement to the Town Council, speaking on behalf of her family, who she said have lived at Portland Avenue for four generations.

“Let’s put this to rest,” she said. The ordinance change was being proposed to let her sister’s business still function on the property, noting that changes had been made over the years since her father had a seal coating business on the property and before him her grandfather operated a woodcutting business.

MacDonald said her family was in opposition to the ordinance change. She said her family had been in the neighborhood for a very long time, but there were a lot of new residences coming in.

Advertisement

“We hope you vote no on this ordinance change tonight,” she said. “Please vote it down. It does not fit the neighborhood.”

If the proposed ordinance change was about businesses and/or uses  in the zone, MacDonald said, than the council could “do whatever you’re going to do.” However, if the proposed zone change was solely about her family’s business, she urged the council to vote it down.

“This has been about us for a couple of years now. Our name has been thrown in the mud a little bit throughout this whole thing and you know what, there are so many bigger things in life, let’s not worry about this,” she said.

“If it’s about us, vote the contractor 1 zone down, we don’t care,” MacDonald said. “It’s minutia compared to what we have going in our lives right now and the mayhem its caused in the neighborhood.”

Mead said the town will conduct a review of businesses in the rural district to determine whether they are in compliance with town ordinance.

— Staff Writer Liz Gotthelf can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 325 or egotthelf@journaltribune.com.

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.