3 min read

A plan to open some long-closed fishing areas off the Northeast coast seems like a useless move that was intended as a gesture rather than a viable means to help New England fishermen to make a living.

The proposal, unveiled last week by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, would allow certain fishermen back into fishing grounds where they’ve long been banned, but it is only making it to light now that environmentalists have been somewhat appeased. Two environmental groups ”“ the Conservation Law Foundation and Earthjustice ”“ sued in May, arguing that regulators were trying to skip a legally required analysis of the effects of the proposed change under the NOAA proposal.

Since that time, NOAA has worked to compromise with the groups, but in doing so has put such measures in place that most fishermen will not be able to access the new areas, and if they are able, they may not want to incur the expense.

That expense will be the cost to hire an independent, on-board catch observer on every trip to monitor and prevent fishing gear entanglements with whales and porpoises and other protected marine mammals. Observers cost roughly $500 to $800 per day, according to an Associated Press article published earlier this week.

It is absurd to think that fishermen ”“ who already have to follow regulations for fishing grounds they use every day ”“ would start to break the law just because they are gaining access to a new fishing area. On the contrary, those who want to take advantage of the new sites would likely be more inclined to play by the rules for fear of shutting the areas down once again.

Advertisement

Requiring observers would also not be cost effective for an industry that is already struggling.

In addition, NOAA also pulled back on the areas that were originally proposed to be reopened under pressure from the groups. Under its newest form, fishermen would only be able to seek access to three of the five closed areas, leaving both zones in the Gulf of Maine closed, while opening portions south and east of Cape Cod in Georges Bank.

Another problem is that only larger fishing boats would have the range to reach the areas, which leaves out a substantial number of the small boat fleet in New England.

It seems as though NOAA put out this information to try to appeal to everyone, although no one seems to be pleased with the news.

Even NOAA’s top official said the plan isn’t a “game changer.” John Bullard, the Northeast regional administrator for NOAA Fisheries, added, “We recognize it’s probably not going to make anyone happy.”

It sounds like he’s right, and due to the environmental concerns, it seems NOAA would have been better served to hold off until more information was gathered on the effects of the ban and fish populations.

Advertisement

The Conservation Law Foundation’s Greg Cunningham said NOAA is acting under political pressure to help fishermen, but they haven’t even finished doing the work to determine what the risks of fishing in the areas could be, according to the AP article.

All around this seems like a half-baked proposal. NOAA needs to go back to the drawing board with all parties that have an interest and come up with a real, working plan to help fishermen while preserving the fish population for the future.

Ӣ Ӣ Ӣ

Today’s editorial was written by City Editor Robyn Burnham on behalf of the Journal Tribune Editorial Board. Questions? Comments? Contact Managing Editor Kristen Schulze Muszynski by calling 282-1535, Ext. 322, or via email at kristenm@journaltribune.com.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.