3 min read

It’s been six years since Cake last released a studio CD of new material. Singer/guitarist John McCrea realizes that gap in time wasn’t ideal. But he and his bandmates had longer-term issues to resolve before the group could resume the creative side of its career.

“A lot of that had to do with having, being forced really, to restructure our business,” McCrea said of the six-year gap. “Musicians can’t, I guess, have the luxury of being spaced-out, drug-addled, throw-the-TV-set-out-of-the-hotel-room-window musicians like they were in the ’70s. The whole music business is imploding, and we kind of had to re-evaluate.”

In a recent phone interview, McCrea said it became clear after Cake released its previous CD, “Pressure Chief,” on Columbia Records that this was no longer the right record company for the band. Fortunately, Columbia agreed to let Cake out of its deal.

“Especially given the overall climate in the music business, we’re not the best candidate for a major-label deal,” McCrea said. “I think even if we have a huge hit with this record (the long-awaited new studio CD, “Showroom of Compassion,” released in January), I don’t think our culture interfaces very well with the corporate culture of a major label.”

But how to move forward wasn’t a simple question. The band did have interest from smaller independent record labels, and that was an option.

In the end, though, McCrea and bandmates — trumpet player Vincent Di Fiore, guitarist Xan McCurdy, bassist Gabriel Nelson and drummer Paulo Baldi — chose to start their own label, Upbeat Records. But they did so with some reservations.

Advertisement

“I’ve certainly watched with some nervousness the careers of people like Prince, who basically just disappeared when they went independent,” McCrea said. “That pretty much scared me.”

To help get an indication of whether the band was making the right move, the group decided to test the waters by releasing a collection of outtakes from previous albums, “B-Sides and Rarities,” in 2007 on Upbeat.

“What we learned from ‘B-Sides and Rarities’ was that we could do it,” McCrea said. “It’s actually a lot more work to have to run your own business. But in some ways, it was much more satisfying, and also a lot safer given the instability in the music business and also just the way (in signing to a record company) you don’t have control over what happens with your album, really.”

If things were changing in major ways with Cake’s business, fans will be happy to know that the group sounds very much like itself on “Showroom of Compassion.”

As on the five previous albums Cake has released since forming in 1991 in Sacramento, Calif., its sound is built primarily around angular (but catchy) guitar lines that are intertwined with horn or keyboard parts. This leaves plenty of space for McCrea to deliver his deceptively melodic vocals in his distinctive deadpan style.

Like Bad Religion, The Ramones or AC/DC, Cake’s sound is so identifiable that it can seem like the group is making the same album over and over again. McCrea is well aware of his group’s singular sound, but feels no one Cake album has been like its predecessor.

Advertisement

And he isn’t about to reshape the band’s sound just for the sake of change.

“Hopefully, the melodies are really different,” he said. “I think that’s the core of the song, and I understand how people want you to re-invent the arrangement process from album to album. I understand that. But what if that individual song doesn’t want that? That’s my point. And yes, we do have a challenge in keeping things fresh.”

The group is pleased with “Showroom of Compassion,” and in fact is slotting several new songs into its live set. Those lucky enough to get tickets to Cake’s sold-out show at the State Theatre will get to hear them on Saturday.

“We’ll probably be playing five or six songs from the new album,” McCrea said. “But that said, we don’t use a setlist. We kind of just ask ourselves what song we feel like playing at the end of each song and play that song. It’s sort of self-preservation so we don’t feel like a machine.

“And we actually do still enjoy playing live shows. I think for me, mostly because we don’t use a setlist.”

 

Alan Sculley is a freelance writer.

 

Tagged:

Comments are no longer available on this story