7 min read

Massabesic High School, is located at 88 West Road in Waterboro. BENJAMIN D. LEVESQUE/Journal Tribune

WATERBORO — Ask a group of Massabesic High School students to make a circle, and you’ll undoubtedly hear of the “Massabesic circle.” The legend, as it is told, is that Massabesic students are incapable of forming a circle with their peers. There are gaps in their circle, or people terribly out of place, and the shape they’ve created is half-egg, half-ellipse.

The circle, a joke between students, represents a broken school system — student apathy, disillusioned faculty, and a lackluster administration. For dedicated students and administrators alike, it was a signal for reform.

Changes began when James Hand was appointed principal of Massabesic High School at the start of the 2016-2017 school year.

Hand, a principal elsewhere in the state prior to his appointment, constructed a plan for improving the school. His challenges were threefold: implementing performance-based education, strengthening students’ abilities, and leading a school within its adverse socioeconomic environment.

The first prong of Hand’s approach involved a Student Advisory Council, formed in 2017. This was a group of students, one representing each grade level, who meet with Hand and his assistant principals to address issues relevant to grades nine through 12, respectively.

Advertisement
Izabella ‘Bella’ Caroulo makes extracurriculars, along with her dog, Khamiko, a part of her daily routine. Bella uses every part of the Massabesic High School palette: she plays flute in its concert band, sings as an advanced chamber singer, and currently serves as secretary of the Choral Department. COURTESY PHOTO/IZABELLA CAROULO

Izabella “Bella” Caroulo of the Class of 2021 represented the freshman class throughout the 2017-2018 school year. Her experience within the committee has continued into the current year, and she is now serving as a sophomore representative.

“I think that this school can be successful,” Caroulo said, “when it has the resources it needs. I think it just needs a push in the right direction.”

Student Advisory Council & Student Council

The Student Advisory Council, Caroulo explained, gave students a direct link to Massabesic administration.

As a committee, they have overseen several events: planning the Class of 2019 graduation, shaping the school’s “Guiding Principles” standards, and directing the eighth-grade transition for Massabesic Middle School students to the high school.

“The benefit of the [Student Advisory Council] is that it makes realistic views into ideas; they aren’t just ideals,” Caroulo said.

Advertisement

She said that she enjoys working with students who are interested in seeing their school improve. These peers, as she said, discuss how they can improve MHS in that year, or the year following, with pragmatic solutions.

According to Caroulo, if she wanted to change one thing, it would be student interest.

“Students (should be) more motivated academically, (with interest in going) to college,” she said.

School isn’t prison, and her less-motivated peers shouldn’t regret the four-year experience, Caroulo said.

While some students are apathetic, those on the Massabesic Student Council are not.

Blake Proctor of the MHS Class of 2020, has served on Student Council since his freshman year. A enthusiastic student, Proctor continually pushes himself as a member of the football team while earning high grades n his courses. He decided to join Student Council on the advice of his peers. 

Advertisement

“I wanted to have an impact on this school, and the students that attend it, in a positive way,” Proctor said. “What better way to (do that) than to be a member of the Student Council?”

In this position, Proctor rose above his peers in service to the school; he was in charge, in part, of the minute details of a perfect MHS, surrounded by those serving in the same respect. His tenure as a member is likely to span into his senior year.

As a team, the Massabesic Student Council organizes pep rallies, homecoming arrangements (including hallway contests and themed days of the week): activities that encourage school spirit outside of the classroom, allowing students to thrive in a comfortable, yet energetic, environment.

Operational level

On an operational level, Proctor says that everyone has a voice in the activities they plan. From the penny wars, to the fifty-fifty raffles, and the class-to-class games during Massabesic’s pep rallies, each member retains a voice. What he envisions is a student body willing to participate in the excitement.

“I want activities and volunteer service ([opportunities) to be (anticipated). For people to want to (participate in) events that are centered around, or brought up by, the Student Council,” he said.  Events that, Proctor said, are ultimately meant to have a positive effect on the school.

Advertisement

Hand, with the help of coordinating staff, has succeeded in promoting student confidence — placing them as leaders of their school. He has worked since his appointment with local and regional administrators, overseeing Massabesic’s streamlined grading system. And, most critically, Hand has guided MHS in recognition of its downfalls.

The most visible example was Massabesic’s District Report Card, a document released by the Maine Department of Education.

James Hand is he principal of Massabesic High School. SUBMITTED PHOTO

The Elementary and Secondary Education Act, formerly known as the No Child Left Behind Act, requires all states, school districts, and schools to provide an annual report card to parents and communities.

As of the 2016-2017 school year, 40 percent of Regional School Unit 57 was economically disadvantaged. Four out of 10 students, across its six towns — Lyman, Line, Waterboro, Shapleigh, Limerick, and Newfield — lived in compromised economic conditions.

The figure was non-specific (with respect to what qualifies as economically disadvantaged), but as a whole, it realized a new image of the district. An image that Hand works to promote as a strength, especially in regards to MHS staff.

“I think these staff are some of the best,” said Hand. “Given the environment they work in on a daily basis, I have no trouble saying I take pride in their performance.”

Advertisement

Qualitative Survey

Hand, indebted to his faculty, distributed a qualitative survey (authored by a Massabesic student), collect in June 2018. Faculty taking the 21-question survey were encouraged to be honest and thorough. The results were used for the “State of the District” report, completed in September.

The document funneled responses into two themes: Student Tone and Facultative Tone & Administration.

Student Tone, according to the responses given, portrayed students primarily as a product of their rearing, and secondly as a product of personal growth. The former, including culture capital (practical knowledge passed from generation-to-generation), explained one factor within Massabesic High School, “[a portion] of students are in survival mode.”

Because students are born into a compromised environment — substance abuse, mild poverty, low income — they lose focus. A portion of students may have already experienced Adverse Child Experiences (ACEs), instances that impact emotional development during childhood (physical abuse, neglect, etc.). In addition to a lack of personal security, a number of responses cited parent disinterest in education as a factor in student apathy.

“I think [the survey] was correct in the socioeconomic aspect of it,” said Hand, “We at Massabesic work in an environment where we deal with these kinds of situations every day. It’s reasonable that a student’s home environment could impact their learning.” MHS has multiple programs working to assist students from all backgrounds.

Advertisement

At the conclusion of Student Tone, the responses advocated for a respectful approach to education, directed at both pupils and proctors. Towards students, faculty must “show integrity, humbleness, a willingness to learn, and a willingness to work with others.”

Facultative Tone & Administration identified teacher-specific conditions like the weight of administrative policies, personal motivation, and the overall tone amongst educators. One response summarized the setting: “There is an overarching feeling of inferiority in the community and in the school: ‘What do you expect? This is Massabesic.’” For the faculty working in June 2018, Massabesic wasn’t an ideal.

“I think there is understandable bias in this case, seeing as it’s the end of the year and some teachers may be venting. But there were big issues, like giving liberty to our teachers,” Hand said.

In breaking apart the “tone,” Hand said that Massabesic High School has been working to grant their teachers greater freedom under his administration. Previously, teachers had felt coerced in their grading. Moreover, teachers had been moved between four grading systems (one to four grade-points, zero to 100 scores, etc.) in as many years. Recent policy changes have lessened this, Hand said.

Performance-Based Education

The implementation of performance-based education (PBE) over the last several years has created further issues, according to responses. A form of curriculum in which students progress based on their proficiency in a standard, rather than their completion of a grade-specific set of standard, PBE has been Massbesic’s greatest shift, but Hand doesn’t see the change as revolutionary or abrasive.

Advertisement

“When I was working as an assistant principal, I was going up to Auburn for a conference … And as I was driving, a wave of pain spread through my arm: I thought I was having a heart attack.” Hand’s heart attack, however, was a pre-existing condition. And he said that the same type of reaction can occur with something new in administration, like performance-based education. In reality, ignoring minute setbacks, PBE has been a success in Massabesic.

The “State of the District” proved vital to understanding where MHS had been. Now, it is moving forward.

The Student Advisory Council coordinated students of each grade level with school administrators. Massabesic Student Council continues to maintain school spirit through campus-wide events, fundraisers, and pep rallies. And as of the 2018-2019 school year, a former Massabesic administrator, John Morin, has launched the Student Leadership Academy, cultivating leadership within a select few (to start).

Hand,  Caroulo and Proctor hope that MHS and its students are on their way up.

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.