4 min read

Members of Congress and the public have diverse views on the proper American reaction. But leaders of both parties have lined up, making strong statements about America’s responsibilities in the face of unacceptable international behavior.

The Syrian crisis has revealed some major issues going well beyond dealing with the Assad regime, which it might help to understand.

One factor is the war in Iraq, now widely seen as wasteful and unnecessary. Countries that had been involved became wary of getting into another Middle East conflict in which there was no direct and immediate threat to them.

The first reaction came from the British Parliament, where much of the Syria debate focused on the belief that the U.K. should avoid another Iraq. In the end, the Parliament voted against action.

Importantly, Prime Minister David Cameron, who advocated punishing Syria, acknowledged Britain is a democracy, and the vote settled the matter. That vote and his decision now echo in the halls of Congress.

Advertisement

Obama seems determined that the United States should act, even alone, rather than allowing Syria to get away with using poison gas. His worry is that if Syria can use gas without punishment, some day another country might use it against American or allied troops.

Acting alone, America would play the role of the world’s policeman. Though clearly still the world’s greatest military power, the U.S. faces the question of whether it has a responsibility to protect the world against illegal acts.

The United Nations was supposed to be the main player in a situation where a country was violating generally agreed international norms, like using poison gas. Will the U.N. be given time to issue a finding on what happened in Syria? Probably not.

Obama obviously believes it is not worth waiting, because the Russians would veto any U.N. action. Would it be better to see if Russia vetoes a finding that Assad used gas on his own people?

Relatively early in the uprising against the Assad regime, the United States said that he must be removed from office. When making that statement, the government had given little thought to what might replace that regime.

The threat of a terrorist takeover of at least part of Syria has emerged as a possibility. Looking back, the Russian position saying there should be negotiations about who governs Syria may seem more prudent than insisting on Assad’s departure.

Advertisement

The situation could look much different now if the U.S. and Russia had jointly called a peace conference many months ago.

Russia seems to be trying to salvage its place as a world power by opposing almost anything the U.S. advocates. But does that mean the America, without doubt a superpower, must reject anything Russia proposes?

At the heart of the current debate in Washington and across the country is whether failure to act against Syria will make the United States look like a “paper tiger.” Much of the influence of a superpower comes from anticipation of its possible actions as much as from its actual use of force.

Obama declared that if Syria used poison gas it would have crossed a red line. His statement implied that the United States would retaliate in some way if the line were crossed.

At that moment, the president unfortunately created the paper tiger. He had no plan in place when he made the statement and had not consulted with any allies.

He believed that an American threat, a warning from the world’s greatest power, would be enough to deter Assad. It appears that it wasn’t.

Advertisement

With nothing done to back his threat, Obama risked revealing that the United States was a paper tiger when it came to Syria and his threats were meaningless, thus undermining American credibility for the future.

Then came the British parliamentary vote. Under the so-called “special relationship,” the Brits are supposed to follow the Americans, but this time they didn’t.

For once, the special relationship could work in reverse. Could the U.S. take its lead from across the pond?

Apparently not. Congress has rallied behind Obama not to protect his reputation but America’s. But there may have been an alternative.

If the U.S. got Russia to agree that Syria used poison gas and should be prevented from doing so again, perhaps the two could then agree to a Syrian peace conference without the precondition that Assad had to be dumped.

That’s a deal that could kill a paper tiger.

— Gordon L. Weil is an author, publisher, consultant, and former official of international organizations and the U.S. and Maine governments.



        Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.